Sunday, December 8, 2019

2019-11-25 Nominees on the Hall of Fame’s 2020 Modern Baseball Era ballot


Q.        Who was the first player to win back to back National League Most Valuable Player Awards not to make it to the Hall of Fame?
Hint:     He played in over 2,000 major league games, but never played in a postseason game that his team won.
Hint:     He posted a .800 career OPS in the stadium sharing his nickname.
A.         DALE MURPHY [SABR Bio]
-  NL MVPs 1982-83
-  2,180 G; 1982 NLCS = STL/ATL 3G to 0
-  He posted a .819 OPS mark at SD’s Jack Murphy Stadium (aka “The Murph”).
FCR -  Bob Kimball, Sutton, Massachusetts
Incorrect guesses:  Tommy Davis, Ernie Banks, Barry Bonds, Roger Maris

TUESDAY
Q.        What Red Sox batter struck out more than any other in the franchise’s history?
Hint:     He is, however, in the top five in Red Sox history in WAR Position Players Offensive WAR, Games played, Plate Appearances, At-Bats, Runs and Hits.
Hint:     He batted out of turn in his very first plate appearance in the majors.
A.         DWIGHT EVANS  [SABR Bio]
-  1,643 K for BOS
-  Any category where he is not the leader, it is almost always only Ted Williams, Carl Yastrzemski, or both, who are ahead of him.
-  As Explained by Retrosheet, “On 16-Sept-1972, Dwight Evans made his major league debut in the bottom of the 6th inning against the CLE when he pinch ran for Reggie Smith.  BOS was leading at the time, 9-0 and Cecil Cooper had already been placed in the game as a pinch runner for Carl Yastrzemski.  Yaz was batting 3rd and Smith 4th in the original lineup.  In the top of the 7th both Cooper and Evans stayed in the G and 3 other defensive replacements were made by mgr Eddie Kasko.  With one out in the bottom of the 8th, Evans batted in Cooper's spot but flew out.  No protest was made by CLE.  The next legal batter should have been Phil Gagliano but Cooper came to the plate and also made an out to end the inning. BOS went on to win 10-0.  Thus, Dwight Evans’ first major league plate appearance was out of order!”
FCR -  Mark Hayne, Dumfries, Virginia
Incorrect guesses:  Ted Williams, Carl Yastrzemski, Jim Rice, David Ortiz, George Scott, Manny Ramirez

WEDNESDAY
Q.        What onetime Blue Jays DH enjoyed three Gold Glove seasons and three Silver Slugger seasons with the last of the former being separated by five seasons from the first of the latter?
Hint:     He was drafted with the 332nd pick his year and yet scouts for another team laughed at what they thought he was a foolish pick.
Hint:     Few disagreed with his herpetological nickname.
A.         DAVE PARKER  [SABR Bio]
-  GG in 1977, 78 & 79.  SS in 1985, 65 & 90.
-  Drafted by PIT w/ the 332nd pick of the 1970 June Draft and yet CIN actually laughed at PIT for what they thought was a wasted pick.  Later Parker had 4 very productive seasons with the Reds.
-  Nickname “Cobra” because when he uncoiled his ferocious swing or potent right arm, the effect on his opponents was often deadly (to their efforts).
FCR -  David Krassin, Los Angeles
Incorrect guesses:  Dave Winfield, John Olerud, Paul Molitor

THURSDAY
Q.        Whose number did the New York Yankee retire even though, in spite of his playing with them his entire career, he never won a World Series with the team?
Hint:     For three consecutive seasons, he won both Gold Glove and Silver Slugger awards.
Hint:     So dominant a player was he at the height of his career that his nickname actually IS the game.
A.         DON MATTINGLY  [SABR Bio
-  Mattingly’s career was precisely sandwiched between Yankee World Series appearances.  NYY was in the WS in 1981 then next in 1996.  His career was 1982 through 1995.
-  GG/SS 1985-87
-  “Donnie Baseball”
FCR -  Dave Serota, Kalamazoo
Incorrect guesses:  Thurman Munson, Mel Stottlemyre, Bill Dickey

THURSDAY SECONDS
Q.        Who is the only first baseman to win MVP honors at the MLB All-Star Game twice?
Hint:     The team he played for during a mere five MLB seasons retired his uniform number; yet his original team —for whom he played 14 seasons— has not.
Hint:     He once said, "The difference between the old ballplayer and the new ballplayer is the jersey.  The old ballplayer cared about the name on the front.  The new ballplayer cares about the name on the back."
Hint:     In his first collegiate at-bat, he clubbed a grand slam to right field over a hill located on the playing field and into a river.
A.         STEVE GARVEY  [SABR Bio]
-  AS MVP 1974 & 1978
-  - Why the Dodgers haven’t followed the Padres’ lead in retiring Garvey’s number 6 is an awkward tale that could have a happy ending very soon.
-  After the opposing pitcher walked the bases full in the first inning, freshman Garvey quickly unloaded them with an opposite-field blast that arced over the quirky standing hill in right field at Michigan State’s Kobs Field and splashed down in the nearby Red Cedar River.
FCR -  Jim Williams, West Allis, Wisconsin
Incorrect guesses:  Dick Allen, Willie McCovey, Will Clark, Jim Thome 

FRIDAY
Q.        Only once in storied history of the New York Yankee have Yankee batters with last names all starting with M hit back-to-back-to back home runs.  The middle batter’s home run was his first in the majors.  Name him.
Hint:     In the vote for rookie of the year at the end of the following season, he missed being elected unanimously by a single, some say misguided, vote.
Hint:     He received an honor from the Yankees that had not been given in over forty years.
A.         THURMAN MUNSON  [SABR Bio
-  In the bottom of the 6th on 10-Aug-1969, Lew Krause served up consecutive home runs to Bobby Murcer, Munson and Gene Michael.  It was the 2nd of Stick’s 2 that year; it was Munson’s first and only.  112 would follow over the next decade.
-  CLE’s Roy Foster took the last vote.  He was out of baseball in fewer than 4 years.
-  Lou Gehrig became NYY captain in 1935, Munson in 1976.
FCR -  Sarah Grynpas, Toronto
Incorrect guesses:  Bobby Murcer, Gil McDougald, Tino Martinez, Mickey Mantle, Roger Maris, Don Mattingly, Tom Tresh, Kevin Maas

SATURDAY
Q.        What catcher missed Hall of Fame election by a single vote?
Hint:     In his first year on the ballot, however, he only received 3.7% of the vote.
Hint:     At the time of his retirement, he led all catchers in career hits and doubles. (Min 70% G @ C)
Hint:     He had more 75-RBI seasons than any catcher.
A.         TED SIMMONS
-  Simmons received 11 votes in the 2018 Modern Baseball Era HOF election, falling just one shy of the 12 (75%) need for election by the 16-member committee.
-  In his first year on the 1994 ballot following retirement in the 1988 season, he received 17 out of 436 votes or 3.7%.
-  Career = 483 2B & 2,472 H
-  Had 13 seasons w/at least 75 RBI.  In 8 of those years he had 90+.  Mike Piazza and Yogi Berra each had 11 seasons of 75..
FCR -  Adam Balutis, Arlington, Virginia
Incorrect guesses:  Yogi Berra, Bob Boone

SATURDAY NIGHT OWL SPECIAL
Q.        Who made his uniform famous by forgetting it?
Hint:     He was the first lead-off batter to hit a home run that cleared the right-field roof at Tiger Stadium.
Hint:     He hit more home runs wearing uniform #1 than any other player.
A.         LOU WHITAKER  [SABR Bio]
-  On his way to the 1985 ASG in Minneapolis, Whitaker forgot his Tiger uniform top and glove in his car at the airport.  His backup jersey was lost enroute by a messenger service.  His solution was to wear a souvenir-store replica jersey with his number “1” stenciled on its back with a felt-tip marker.  He used a Cleveland Indians batting helmet and he borrowed a glove from Cal Ripken.  The Smithsonian Institution was intrigued by this tale of forgetfulness.  The Smithsonian now has his uniform in its vast collection.  Extensive research could not, however, determine if they have the original lost one, the misplaced delivery one or the one actually worn that day by Whitaker who went 0-2 with it.
- Roof-clearing HR hit 13-May-1985 in the bottom of the 1st off Burt Hooton..
- 244 career HR wearing #1
FCR -  Robert Osman, Great Neck, New York
Incorrect guesses:  Ty Cobb, Ricky Henderson , Reggie Jackson, Ron LeFlore

WEEKEND BONUS
Q.        Who was a teammate of both Hall of Famers Early Wynn and Deion Sanders?
Hint:     Although he pitched mostly left-handed, he claims his right arm should be credited for his last 164 wins after he took a year off.
Hint:     While in high school, he had been recruited by Adolph Rupp to play basketball for the University of Kentucky.
A.         TOMMY JOHN  [SABR Bio]
-  In his first MLB year in CLE in 1963, veteran pitcher Early Wynn was one of his teammates.  Was a teammate of Sanders with NYY in Deion’s first season in the majors, 1989.  Was a teammate of NFL HOF Sanders on the 1989 NYY, Deion’s debut season, but John’s last.  Only Nolan Ryan and Cap Anson played more major league seasons than Tommy John’s 26.  [Further research has revealed that the Yanks released John 30-May-1989 - one day before the LA Times says they called up Sanders.]
-  John earned 164 of his 286 wins after his famous surgery, performed by Dr. Frank Jobe in September 1974. It was deemed necessary after John permanently damaged his left ulnar collateral ligament. A tendon from his right forearm was transplanted into his left elbow and the rest is history.
-  He might have played on national championship basketball teams at Kentucky, but he did get to play in 3 World Series, 1977, 78 & 81.
FCR -  Brett Moore, Studio City, California
Incorrect guesses:  Phil Niekro, Sam McDowell

SUNDAY
Q.        Who did Red Barber say was as important to baseball as Babe Ruth, Jackie Robinson and Branch Rickey?
Hint:     Although he spent the bulk of his career in the Bronx, Brooklyn and Manhattan he never played for the Yankees, Dodgers, Giants or Mets.
Hint:     Despite strong support from former Baseball Commissioners Bud Selig and Fay Vincent (and countless others), he still came up short in his last attempt for election to the Baseball Hall of Fame.
A.         MARVIN MILLER  [SABR Bio]
-  Miller became executive director of the MLBPA (Major League Baseball Players Association) and helped secure rights for players never dreamed of in the previous century of the majors.
-  Miller was born in the Bronx in 1917, lived most of his life in Flatbush and died in Manhattan in 2012.
-  Needing 12 of the 16 votes cast by the Expansion Era Veterans committee in 2011, he came up just one vote shy of enshrinement.
FCR -  Patrick Roth, Chicago
Incorrect guesses:  Minnie Minoso, Gil Hodges, Walter O'Malley, Judge Landis, Mel Allen, Buck O’Neil, Bill Shea

WEEKLY THEME – Nominees on the Hall of Fame’s 2020 Modern Baseball Era ballot. A panel of 16 voters (living Hall of Famers along with a few other executives and one or two members of the media) will be tasked with voting for up to 4 out of the 10 candidates.  The names of these 16 voters will likely not be revealed until a week before the actual vote is taken.  In order to be elected to the Hall, a candidate needs 12 votes (75%).  The 16 members of the committee will meet at December’s Winter Meetings in San Diego and the inductees (if any) will be announced on Sunday, December 8th.

First Correct Respondent to Identify Theme – Quentin Wittrock , Minnesota (after Murphy!)

Incorrect theme guesses:

Sat          -  Players eligible for HOF with most WAR in the 70s and 80s that are not in the HOF.

Sun        -  Theme most deserving HOF members under consideration by veterans committee
-       People that I want in the Hall of Fame but, alas will probably not get in because of lack of knowledge. 










2019-11-18 Hall of Fame pitchers who lost no-hit bids with two out in the ninth inning or later


Q.        What durable pitcher passed away in 1955 prompting baseball to create an award honoring his legacy?
Hint:     His gold career totals indicating an all-time career record in Baseball-Reference are almost comically numerous.
Hint:     He threw the first pitch ever thrown in a World Series game in the modern era.
A.         CY YOUNG  [SABR Bio]
-  The Cy Young Award for excellence in pitching was first awarded in 1956.  Brooklyn’s Don Newcombe was the first winner.
-  He is the all-time leader in Wins (511), Losses (315), Games Started (815), Compete Games (749), Innings Pitched (7,356), Hits surrendered (7,092), Earned Runs (2,147) and Batters Faced (29,565).
-  On 01-Oct-1903 he face Ginger Beaumont of the Pirates and got him to fly out to center field.
FCR -  Mark Manuel, Kenai, Alaska
Incorrect guesses:  Joe McGinnity

TUESDAY
Q.        Who is still the only pitcher to strike out ten consecutive batters in a major league game?
Hint:     He was the first Baseball Digest “Player of the Year” winner.
Hint:     His condition of green thumb was never investigated as a possible pitching advantage.
A.         TOM SEAVER  [SABR Bio]
-  10 straight Ks = 22-Apr-1970
-  Won the BB Digest POY in 1969
-  A successful farmer, he owns a successful vineyard in northern California.
FCR -  Dan Greder, Ames, Iowa
Incorrect guesses:  Catfish Hunter

TUESDAY BONUS
Q.        What legendary pitcher holds the rookie record for wins in a season in the modern era?
Hint:     He won the pitching triple crown for three consecutive seasons.
Hint:     His wife was once portrayed by Doris Day in a major motion picture.
-  He led the majors with 28 wins in his debut year 1911.  (Modern era = 1901- )
-  Pitching TC 1915, 16 & 17 (also won it in 1920)
-  Alexander’s wife Aimee was played in the fictionalized 1952 movie about his life, The Winning Team, by Doris Day.  His part was played by a young actor named Ronald Reagan.
FCR -  Leonard Levin, Providence
Incorrect guesses:  Don Drysdale, Steve Carlton, Babe Ruth, Walter Johnson, Dizzy Dean, Sandy Koufax, Bob Feller, Carl Hubbell

WEDNESDAY
Q.        Who was the first National League pitcher to win an MVP?
Hint:     Who was the first pitcher to win his league’s ERA title by >1.00 run?
Hint:     His teammates called him “Dead Shot” because he backed up his boasts about his prowess with a revolver by slicing a card in 2 edgewise & shooting through the bottom of a bottle w/o breaking the neck.
A.         DAZZY VANCE [SABR Bio]
-  1924 MVP for BRO.  He could hardly be denied.  He led the majors, not just the NL in wins, ERA, complete games, Ks, ERA+, FIP, WHIP, H9, SO9 & SO/W.
-  His ERA of 2.61 was 1.26 runs better than runner-up Carl Hubbell n 1930.
FCR -  John Burbridge, Seven Valleys, Pennsylvania
Incorrect guesses:  Carl Hubbell, Dizzy Dean, Don Newcombe, Jim Konstanty, Bob Gibson, Clayton Kershaw

MIDWEEK BONUS
Q.        What multiple-Cy-Young-Award winner had a season with more than ten starts but ended that season with an ERA over 10.0?
Hint:     His ERA when he won his first Cy Young Award was the highest of winner in the past eighteen seasons.
Hint:     His tibia was broken by a line drive, ending his season before the All-Star break.
Hint:     He was certainly on pace to make the All-Star team when it happened.
A.         ROY HALLADAY  [SABR Bio]
-  13 GS, 10.64 ERA in 2000 for TOR
-  CYA in 2003 with an ERA of 3.25
-  Bone-breaking liner off the bat of the Rangers’ Kevin Mench 08-Jul-2005
-  Had a record of 12-5 w/ERA of 2.41 & 108 K at the time of the accident.  Halladay got hurt on a Friday and the '05 All-Star Game was played the following Tuesday.  He's listed as a reserve by baseball-reference.
FCR -  Michael Caragliano, Flushing, New York
Incorrect guesses:  Dizzy Dean, Corey Kluber, Johan Santana, Bob Gibson, Bartolo Colon, David Cone, Roger   Clemens

THURSDAY
Q.        What one-time Phillies pitcher had the largest margin between first and second place for his league’s ERA title?
Hint:     He was the first Dodger rookie to pitch in sixty games.
Hint:     His cousin pitched for six teams in seven years in the majors.
Hint:     On year for an expansion team he began the season with eight win and no losses (although not in their expansion year).
A.         PEDRO MARTINEZ  [SABR Bio]
-  In 2000, Pedro’s ERA  for BOS was 1.74 and Clemens’ was 3.70 was in second place in the AL for a delta of nearly 2 full runs.
   -  Appeared in 65 G for the 1993 LAD.  Threw 107 innings for a 10-5 record.
-  Cousin = Denny Bautista
-  8-0 start for MON in 1997.
FCR -  Humbert Kilanowski, Providence
Incorrect guesses:  Burt Hooton, John Denny, Mike Marshall, Pedro Astacio

FRIDAY
Q.        Who was the third native of Louisiana to be inducted into the Hall of Fame?
Hint:     He once pitched a no-hitter against the Red Sox where he walked the first batter then was otherwise perfect through 6⅓ innings.  An error by his shortstop allowed the only other runner.
Hint:     Although he never won the award, he received MVP votes nine times.
Hint:     Playing his entire major league career for just one team, he won more than 250 games.
A.         TED LYONS  [SABR Bio]
-  HOF in 1955 after Mel Ott (1951) and Bill Dickey (1954)
-  No-no 21-Aug-1926
-  Entire 21-year career spent w/CHW.  260-230 record.
FCR -  Steve Berman, Bergenfield, New Jersey
Incorrect guesses:  Vida Blue, Bob Gibson, Ron Guidry, Andy Pettitte

SATURDAY
Q.        Who was the winning pitcher in Cal Ripken's 2,131st consecutive game?
Hint:     He was the surprise reliever who held off the Red Sox in the game where Aaron Boone hit his triumphant ninth-inning home run to win the ALCS.
Hint:     He played baseball for a university that has no mascot.
Hint:     A persistent rumor in his hometown holds that he purposely lowered his high school GPA to avoid being valedictorian so he would not have to give a graduation speech.
A.         MIKE MUSSINA
-  Ripken G 06-Sep-1995
-  Mussina came in to replace Roger Clemens in the 4th inning then completed the 5th & 6th in G 7 16-Oct-2003.
-  After several tortured changes, Stanford University has had no official mascot since 1981.  Cardinal red is the school’s official color.
FCR -  John Romps, Dover New Hampshire
Incorrect guesses:  David Cone, Tim Wakefield, Andy Pettitte, Mike Boddicker

WEEKEND BONUS
Q.        What BBTL hurler surrendered Babe Ruth’s first Yankee home run?
Hint:     He got the first win and last win in the Yankees first World Series Championship.
Hint:     His delivery was so smooth that Grantland Rice said, “He pitched each game with the ease and coolness of a practice session.”
A.         HERB PENNOCK  [SABR Bio]
-  Pennock was pitching for BOS when Ruth took him deep 01-May-1920.  [Bats Both, Throws Left]
-  1923 WS; Pennock won G 2 & G 6.
   Rice was the preeminent sportswriter in the first half of the 20th century.
FCR -  Bobby Salerno, Seminole, Florida
Incorrect guesses:  Bob Shawkey, Carl Mays, Waite Hoyt

SUNDAY
Q.        Which Ivy League pitching coach alone amassed more career complete games than the entire total of complete games accumulated by all pitchers in both leagues over MLB’s six most recent seasons combined?
Hint:     His windup was such that he faced second base then whirled around and threw with excellent accuracy, often startling the batter.
Hint:     Although born in a family of comfortable circumstance, his last years on earth were spent in misery.
A.         JOHN CLARKSON  [SABR Bio]
-  Coached at Dartmouth, Harvard & Yale.  Had 485 CG compared to 451 CG in MLB 2014-19.
-  Billy Sunday said, “Clarkson could put more turns and twists into a ball than any pitcher I ever saw.”  Hall of Famer Sam Thompson, famed outfielder with Detroit and Philadelphia, said, “I faced him in scores of games and I can truthfully say that never in all that time did I get a pitch that came where I expected it or in the way in which I guessed it was coming.”
-  He spent much of the last four years of his life in mental hospitals and was accused of the brutal murder of his wife.
FCR -  David Gordon, Chevy Chase, Maryland
Incorrect guesses:  Christy Mathewson, Tim Keefe, Smoky Joe Wood, Ewell Blackwell, Jack Taylor, Ed Walsh, Cy Young, George Earnshaw


WEEKLY THEME – Hall of Fame pitchers who lost no-hit bids with two out in the ninth inning or later.

Pitcher            Date                     Hit Notes
Clarkson......... 26-May-1892...... 1B by Hugh Jennings
Young............. 23-Jul-1896 ....... 1B by Ed Delahanty
Pennock......... 14-Apr-1915........ 1B by Harry Hooper.......... Beat E. Shore 2-0
Alexander....... 05-Jun-1915....... 1B by Arthur Butler
Vance............. 17-Jun-1923....... 1B by Sammy Bohne
Lyons............. 19-Sep-1925....... 1B by Bobby Veach.......... Won 17-0
Seaver............ 24-Sep-1975....... 1B by Joe Wallis............... Also pitched 10th
Martinez......... 05-Jun-1995....... 1B Bip Roberts.................. 9 perfect innings, pulled after hit in 10th
Halladay......... 27-Sep-1998....... HR by Bobby Higginson.... 2nd career start
Mussina.......... 02-Sep-2001....... PH 1B by Carl Everett

First Correct Respondent to Identify ThemeSarah Grynpas, Toronto (After Halladay)

Incorrect theme guesses:

Tuesday -  300 game winners with career era under 3.00
               -  Hall of Famers with the highest career winning percentage
               -  World Series starting pitchers
               -  Pitchers with over 60 shutouts
            -           25+ game winners who lost a world series game the same season

Wed        -  Pitchers who lost no-hit bids in the bottom of the ninth
               -  Pitchers who lost no-hit bids in the bottom of the ninth in the bottom of the ninth with 2 outs
               -  Hall of Fame pitchers (or maybe just Hall of Famers depending on how the week plays out) who went by names other than their given first names (i.e. George Thomas Seaver, Denton True Young, Harry Leroy Halladay, etc.)

Sunday   -  Players with the best World Series WHIP's