Monday, June 17, 2024

2024-06-10 Top Hall of Famers by WAR (100+) who were not elected on the first ballot

MONDAY  — 10-Jun

Q.  Who is the only major leaguer named for and portrayed by U.S. presidents?

Hint: #1  At the height of his pitching career, he had a season where he led the majors in games started, complete games, shutouts, ERA, innings pitched and ERA+.  His number of shutouts that year has never been topped.

Hint: #2  His career shutout total is the best by a National Leaguer since 1876.

Hint: #3  He had a nickname with no relationship with his real name.

A.  GROVER CLEVELAND ALEXANDER  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  In 1952, Warner Bros. released a biopic of Alexander called “The Winning Team”, starring Ronald Reagan & Doris Day.

-  #1  Playing for the Phillies in 1916, Alexander had 45 GS, 38 CG, 16 SHO, a 1.55 ERA, 389.0 IP & a 172 ERA+.

-  #2  His 90 career SHOs trail only Walter Johnson’s 110.

-  #3  Alexander’s father was a Democrat & Alexander was born during the 1st term of U.S. President Grover Cleveland, a Democrat, so his parents named him for Cleveland. His nickname evolved into “Pete” Alexander, from the names of characters in a series of early silent film westerns, characters he was said to resemble.

FCR -  Gerald Price, Lancaster, California

Incorrect guesses:  Cy Young, Rube Waddell

 

 

TUESDAY  — 11-Jun

Q.  Who holds the record in organized baseball for the single-season highest batting average in the twentieth century?

Hint: #1  Craig Biggio passed him for the most career doubles by a right-handed batter.

Hint: #2  He was the first American Leaguer with a WAR of 10.0 in one season.

A.  NAPOLEON LAJOIE   [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  Lajoie’s .426 in 1901 for Connie Mack’s freshly minted Philadelphia A’s has never been topped in the AL, NL or PL. [Horsehide Trivia uses the very convenient “organized baseball” as defined in The Dickson Baseball Dictionary, 3rd edition, p. 608]  Perhaps a new, convenient term will emerge soon.

-  #1  Biggio hit his 658th 2B to become the right-handed batter with the most career doubles, passing Lajoie’s 657 total.  Brett has since been passed by Albert Pujols.

-  #2  Lajoie’s 10.0 WAR in 1906 led both leagues.

FCR -  Thomas Nester, Fort Myers, Florida

Incorrect guesses:  George Sisler, Ichiro Suzuki, Rogers Hornsby, Ty Cobb, Ted Williams, Joe Jackson, Tetelo Vargas, Gary Redus, Josh Gibson, Cool Papa Bell

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY  — 12-Jun

Q.  Who was the first Red Sox pitcher to  lead the American League in ERA?

Hint: #1  He was the first native of Ohio inducted in the Hall of Fame.

Hint: #2  His career record goes orange at least eight times.

Hint: #3  The timing of his passing was instrumental in our seeing and hearing his name quite often now.

A.  CY YOUNG   [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  Young’s 1.62 in 1901 was the best in either league that year.  No Red Sox pitcher would have won it before that because the franchise didn’t exist before that.  They were called the Boston Americans in their early years.

-  #1  Young was born in Newcomerstown, OH.

-  #2  Young doesn’t just lead in wins (511).  He’s also the career pitching leader in losses (315), games started (815), complete games (749), innings pitched (7,356.0), hits surrendered (7,092), earned runs surrendered (2,147) & batters faced (29,565).

-  #3  Young died 04-Nov-1955.  The 1st CYA was awarded in 1956.

FCR -  Jaime Aron, Dallas

Incorrect guesses: 

 

 

MIDWEEK BONUS  — 12-Jun

Q.  Measured by career WAR, who is the greatest left-handed pitcher ever?

Hint: #1  He was the most recent left-handed pitcher to win thirty games in a season.

Hint: #2  Jimmie Foxx’s first major league hit at the age of 17, came while pinch-hitting for him.

A.  LEFTY GROVE   [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  Grove’s career War is 106.8.  The other top lefty hurlers are Randy Johnson (101.1), Warren Spahn (100.1), Eddie Plank (90.9), Steve Carlton (90.2)

-  #1  Grove had 31 W in 1931 for PHA.

-  #2  Foxx pinch hit for Grove in the 8th inning 01-May-1925.

FCR -  Matt Dicker, Chicago

Incorrect guesses:  Warren Spahn

 

 

THURSDAY  — 13-Jun

Q.  Which Double Unique centerfielder was Joe DiMaggio’s childhood idol?

Hint: #1  He (not Joe) twice had seasons when he made more than ten unassisted double plays from center field.

Hint: #2  He was the first manager to win a World Series title in his first full year as a manager.

A.  TRIS SPEAKER   [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  Great choice, Joe.  Speaker is still considered by many to be the best fielding centerfielder ever.  His total of 449 OF assists leads everybody.  Ty Cobb is an impressive but distant 392.  Double-Unique status detailed here.

-  #1  CF UDPs = 12 in 1909 & 14 in 1911.  No other outfielder turned more career DP, a heady 143.  Cobb’s number is impressive but distant = 105.

-  #2  As player/manager of CLE in 1920, he led them to a 5-2 WS victory over BRO.

FCR -  Sarah Grynpas, Philadelphia

Incorrect guesses:  Rogers Hornsby, Nap Lajoie

 

 

FRIDAY — 14-Jun

Q.  Who was the first batter to lead his league in hits and walks in the same season?

Hint: #1  No National League right-handed batter ever had more hits in a season.

Hint: #2  Only Willie Mays has as many National League seasons with a WAR of 10.0 or more.

A.  ROGERS HORNSBY   [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  Playing for STL in 1924, Hornsby led the majors w/227 H & led the NL w/89 BB.  It has since been done by Phillies Richie Ashburn in 1958 & Lenny Dykstra in 1993.  No American Leaguer ha even done it.

-  #1  In 1922 he racked up 250 H.

-  #2  Hornsby’s top WAR seasons = 10.8 in 1921; 10.1 in 1922; 12.1 in 1924; 10.2 in 1925; 10.2 in 1927; & 10.6 in 1929.  Mays did it in 1954, 58, 62-65.   In the AL, Walter Johnson has 7 such, but the all-time leader is Babe Ruth with 9.

FCR -  Tom Cleary, Macungie, Pennsylvania

Incorrect guesses:  Barry Bonds, Henry Aaron, Stan Musial, Bill Terry

 

 

SATURDAY — 15-Jun

Q.  Who among National League Hall of Famers has the most seasons with at least one hundred bases‑on-balls each?

Hint: #1  He led his league in home runs six times, but not once with a home run total over forty and not once with a total that led the majors

Hint: #2  He has an honored place in baseball’s second-most (OK, maybe third-most) famous poem.

A.  MEL OTT  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  BBs     Year

113..... 1929

103..... 1930

100..... 1932

111..... 1936

102..... 1937

118..... 1938

100..... 1939

100..... 1940

100..... 1941

109..... 1942

(In the AL, Ruth, Gehrig, Williams, Mantle & Frank Thomas each had 10+ 100-BB seasons.)

-  #1  Ott led the NL in HR in

1932 (38)*;

1934 (35)*;

1936 (33);

1937 (31)*;

1938 (36); &

1942 (30).

*Tied

-  #2  “Line-Up for Yesterday: An ABC of Baseball Immortals” is a poem written by Ogden Nash for the January 1949 issue of SPORT Magazine.  In it, Nash dedicates each letter of the alphabet to a famous player, 24 in all & includes a clever reference to himself.  I would position it behind only “Casey at the Bat” & “Baseball’s Sad Lexicon”.

FCR -  Victor Piacentile, Yorktown Heights, New York

Incorrect guesses:  King Kelly, Henry Aaron, Johnny Evers, Frank Chance, Gavvy Cravath, Chuck Klein, Ralph Kiner, Mike Schmidt

 

 

SUNDAY  — 09-Jun

Q.  Whose .333 batting average (including individual qualifying seasons of .360, .365 and .372) belies the fact that never once did his batting average for the year lead his league?

Hint: #1  He turned down the Yankees’ manager job.

Hint: #2  His son played baseball for Yale University, helping them win the Ivy League Championship.

A.  EDDIE COLLINS  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  Three times, 1909, 1914 & 1915, the only AL batter he trailed was Ty Cobb.  He finished in the Top Ten in the AL 15 X in the 18 seasons when had played at least 100 games & in the Top Five 11 X.

-  #1  He was offered the NYY manager’s job following the death of Miller Huggins at the end of the 1929 season but elected to stay in Philadelphia with Connie Mack’s A's.  He coached there 1929-32.

-  #2  Collins’ son, Eddie Collins Jr. also played three seasons for PHA.

FCR -  Tim Luca, San Mateo, California

Incorrect guesses:  Paul Waner

 

 

 

WEEK’S THEME – Top Hall of Famers by WAR (100+) who were not elected on the first ballot

 

Player              Eligible         Elected   WAR (Career)- - - -Rank

Alexander........... 1936-37............. 1938............. 119.6....... 15th

Collins................. 1936-38............. 1939............. 124.3....... 13th

Grove.................. 1944-46............. 1947............. 106.8....... 26th

Hornsby.............. 1938-41............. 1942............. 127.0....... 12th

Lajoie.................. 1936.................. 1937............. 106.9....... 24th

Ott....................... 1949-50............. 1951............. 110.9....... 20th

Speaker.............. 1936.................. 1937............. 134.9......... 9th

Young................. 1936.................. 1937............. 163.6......... 3rd

 

First Correct Respondent identifying theme

 

 

Incorrect theme guesses:

 

Mon     -  Pitchers with 100 wins for two franchises

 

Tues    -  Members of the First Hall of Fame Class, who also won Triple Crowns

-   A ball signed by Babe Ruth, Honus Wagner, Ty Cobb, Cy Young, Tris Speaker, George Sisler, Walter Johnson, Connie Mack, Nap Lajoie, Eddie Collins, and Pete Alexander, on the day they all entered the Baseball Hall of Fame sold for $623,369

-   Living members of HOF who were in attendance on the day the HOF was officially dedicated

-   Players with most votes who did not make the Hall of Fame in the first Election

-   Players with the most votes in the second Hall of Fame election year

-   Members of the Hall of Fame class who were inducted in '39 who also won the Triple Crown

-   Hall of Famers at the inaugural hall of fame induction ceremony

-   Inductees at the time of the Baseball Hall of Fame's opening in 1939

-   Players in the first Hall of Fame vote who got over 50% but didn't get in in the first year

-   The first players elected to the Hall of Fame after the initial 5

 

Sun      -  First ballot HoF'er

 

If you know someone who would enjoy receiving daily Horsehide Trivia questions, they need only drop an email message to horsehidetrivi@aol.com.

 

Click here => FULL WEEK to see this week’s quiz, compete with questions, answers and even the incorrect guesses.

 

Scroll back to see previous Horsehide Trivia posts as far back as 2010.  Quizzes before that may also be available upon request.

 

 

Horsehide Trivia encourages independent research.  ⚾️

 

Additional Hall of Famers also not elected on the first ballot with high (60.0+) Career WAR

 

Player                 Elected       Eligible        Career WAR

Eddie Mathews.......... 1978........ 1974-77............ 95.9

Phil Niekro................. 1997........ 1993-96............ 95.9

Bert Blyleven.............. 2011...... 1998-2010.......... 94.5

Jimmie Foxx............... 1951........ 1944-50............ 93.0

Gaylord Perry............. 1991........ 1989-90............ 90.0

Robin Roberts............ 1976........ 1973-75............ 86.1

Fergie Jenkins........... 1991........ 1989-90............ 84.2

Joe DiMaggio............. 1955........ 1952-54............ 79.1

Paul Waner................ 1952........ 1946-51............ 74.8

Harry Heilman............ 1952........ 1941-51............ 72.2

Frankie Frisch............ 1947........ 1942-46............ 71.8

Ted Lyons.................. 1955...... 1946-1944.......... 70.6

Gary Carter................ 2003...... 1998-2002.......... 70.2

Carl Hubbell............... 1947........ 1945-46............ 68.5

Carlton Fisk................ 2000........... 1999............... 68.5

Al Simmons................ 1953........ 1946-52............ 68.3

Ryne Sandberg.......... 2005........ 2003-04............ 67.9

Don Drysdale............. 1984...... 1975-1983.......... 67.1

Roberto Alomar.......... 2011........... 2010............... 67.0

Don Sutton................. 1998........ 1994-97............ 66.7

Duke Snider............... 1980........ 1970-79............ 65.9

Andre Dawson........... 2010........ 2002-09............ 64.9

Joe Cronin.................. 1956........ 1947-55............ 64.7

Billy Williams.............. 1987........ 1982-86............ 63.6

Lou Boudreau............ 1970........ 1961-69............ 63.2

Juan Marichal............ 1983........ 1981-82............ 62.9

Early Wynn................ 1972........ 1969-71............ 61.0

Harmon Killebrew...... 1984........ 1981-83............ 60.3

Dazzy Vance.............. 1955...... 1939-1954.......... 60.3

 

Notable Non-Hall of Famers w/high Career WAR

 

Barry Bonds......................................................... 162.8

Roge Clemens..................................................... 139.2

Alex Rodriguez.................................................... 117.6

Albert Pujols......................................................... 101.4

Mike Trout.............................................................. 86.2

Justin Verlander..................................................... 81.6

Clayton Kershaw................................................... 79.7

Pete Rose.............................................................. 79.5

Curt Schilling.......................................................... 79.5

Zach Greinke......................................................... 77.5

Max Scherzer......................................................... 75.0

Rafael Palmeiro..................................................... 71.9

Joe Jackson........................................................... 62.2

Sammy Sosa......................................................... 58.6

No comments:

Post a Comment