Sunday, August 11, 2024

2024-08-05 Statistical Leaders for the 1890 Players’ League

MONDAY  — 05-Aug

Q.  Who won a season batting average title with the highest average ever recorded in major league history?

Hint: #1  He was the first player to have a string of more than five consecutive seasons with at least 100 RBI?

Hint: #2  A Hall of Fame manager once said about him, “He plays the outfield carrying a crystal ball.  He is always there to make the catch.”

A.  HUGH DUFFY  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  Duffy hit .440* (Not a typo) in 1894 with Boston’s National League team, ATL today. 

-  #1  Duffy did it 7 times in a row.  From 1893-99 he registered 118, 145, 100, 113, 129, 108 & 102 respectively.  He didn’t lead the league even once in that run even though he had in 1891 with 110.

-  #2  Cap Anson, player/manager of the Chicago Colts, Cubs today.  His comment is ironic since Anson was the one who rejected Duffy earlier because he, “…looked more like a batboy than a player.”

FCR -  Jim Casey, Savannah

* Please read the introduction here.

Incorrect guesses:  Hugh Kelly, Ty Cobb, Josh Gibson, Willie Mays, Nap Lajoie, Oscar Charleston, Rogers Hornsby, Bill Terry

 

 

TUESDAY  — 06-Aug

Q.  Whose record for most total bases in one National League game did Chuck Klein break?

Hint: #1  He led the National League in OPS and OPS+ for six straight years.

Hint: #2  He served as a night watchman & press box attendant at the Polo Grounds after he retired.

A.  DAN BROUTHERS [Wiki Bio]

-  Ans.  Brouthers had 15 TB in a G on 10-Sep-1886.  Klein racked up 16 in a G on 10-Jul-1936.

-  #1  Look for the black ink here.

-  #2  At least it kept him close to the game.

FCR -  Victor Piacentile, Yorktown Heights, New York

Incorrect guesses:  Rogers Hornsby, Jesse Burkett, Wee Willie Keeler, Mel Ott Jim Bottomley, Frankie Frisch, Zack Wheat, George Burns

 

 

TUESDAY TWICE — 06-Aug

Q.  Which BBTL corner infielder had his twenty-three-year old career home run record broken by an erstwhile Boston pitcher?

Hint: #1  He was the first player to win a game with a grand slam with two outs in the bottom of the ninth inning.

Hint: #2  He purchased a minor league team after his playing days.

A.  ROGER CONNOR  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  Connor retired in 1897 with 138 career HR.  Babe Ruth’s 139th was hit on 18-Jul-1921.  Brouthers’ 58th had passed the career total of Harry Stovey.  Connor was a switch-hitter and threw lefty.

-  #1  On the 10-Sep-1881

-  #2  He bought the Waterbury team of the Connecticut League.

FCR -  Gabe Kinstlinger, Reisterstown, Maryland

Incorrect guesses:  Gavvy Cravath, Frank Baker, Socks Seybold, Rabbit Benton

 

 

WEDNESDAY  — 07-Aug

Q.  Which first baseman hit at least nineteen triples each year six years in a row.

Hint: #1  He umpired one major league game toward the end of his career.

Hint: #2  He was known to hide the baseball under a base in order to entice a runner to take a lead.

A.  JAKE BECKLEY  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  With 22 n 1890 and 19 each 1891-1895, every year but 1 in the Top 5.

-  #1  Showing he much he was universally trusted, he was the home plate ump on 09-Sep-1906(2) between his Cards & CIN.  The latter prevailed.

-  #2  According to Baseball, the Biographical Encyclopedia, Beckley “developed a hidden ball trick that was all his own: he hid the ball under a corner of the base, and when the runner took a lead, Beckley quickly reached under the base, grabbed the ball, and tagged the runner out. One day he reportedly lifted the wrong corner of the bag, and Honus Wagner zipped down to second, laughing all the way.”  Much thanks to 25-year Horsehide Trivia reader Bill Deane for that research morsel.  It comes directly from Bill’s book, Finding the Hidden-Ball Trick (Rowman & Littlefield, 2015).

FCR -  Jon Symons, Winnipeg

Incorrect guesses:  Hal Chase, Cap Anson, Frank Chance, Charles Comiskey, Sam Crawford, George Sisler, Cy Young

 

 

MIDWEEK BONUS  — 07-Aug

Q.  Which member of the pitching staff of the St. Louis Browns had a career year with sixty-four starts and sixty-four complete games with an ERA under 2.00 yet didn’t get a single vote for the Cy Young Award?

Hint: #1  His team captured the league crown that year with ninety-two wins, forty-five of which were his.

Hint: #2  He never attended a baseball game after he retired at age twenty-nine.

A.  SILVER KING  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  In 1888 for STL in the AA.  CYA not awarded until 1955.  Not aware of any similar recognition for excellent pitching.  Silver King passed away in 1938.

-  #1  STL was in the American Association, a major league 1882-1891.

-  #2  The St. Louis Post-Dispatch said in 1918, Silver King—Charles Frederick Koenig—had not attended a baseball game since his career ended 20 years earlier.

FCR -  Richard Klee, North Hollywood, California

Incorrect guesses:  George Bradley, Bob Caruthers, Nim Goggin, Charles Radbourn,

 

 

THURSDAY  — 08-Aug

Q.  Who is the only player to lead his league in home runs and triples in the same season twice?

Hint: #1  He changed his name so his mother would not see his name in box scores.

Hint: #2  He retired with more runs scored than games played.

A.  HARRY STOVEY  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  As a rookie with the 1880 Worcester Ruby Legs, Stovey led the NL with 14 3B & 6 HR.  Eleven years later with the 1891 NL Boston team, Stovey again led in both.  That year he had 20 3B & 16 HR.

-  #1  Stovey’s mother, like many people of her time, considered it unsavory to be a ballplayer.  Stowe was the family name

-  #2  Played in 1,489 G; scored 1,495 R.  This feat has only been duplicated by his contemporaries, Billy Hamilton and George Gore.

FCR -  Richard Klee, North Hollywood, California

Incorrect guesses:  Jim Bottomley, Harry Lumley

 

 

FRIDAY  — 09-Aug

Q.  Which rookie led the majors in batting average, on-base percentage and OPS+?

Hint: #1  During games he refused to slide and often stood perched on one leg.

Hint: #2  He named each of his bats and kept hundreds of them in his mother’s basement.

Hint: #3  He was unnecessarily incarcerated in an insane asylum after his retirement.

A.  PETE BROWNING  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  In 1882 in the Louisville franchise of the American Association, hit .378, had an OBP of .430 & managed an OPS+ of 223!  He outhit the NL’s Dan Brouthers in all 3 categories.

-  #1  He was well-known for his frequent odd behavior.

-  #2  He led a life littered with eccentricities.

-  #3 Browning suffered from mastoiditis, a painful condition that left him nearly deaf.  Undiagnosed, it led to frequent misunderstandings.

FCR -  Daniel Wilson, St. Paul, Minnesota

Incorrect guesses:  Jimmy Piersall, Tony Oliva, Hughie Jennings, Joe Sewell

 

 

SATURDAY  — 10-Aug

Q.  Who  was the first player to lead his league in RBI hitting fewer than five home runs that same season?

Hint: #1  The award given annually by the Canadian Baseball Hall of Fame to the top Canadian in baseball is name for him.

Hint: #2  In his best season he hit .492.

A.  TIP O’NEILL  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  In 1886, O’Neill had 103 RBI but only 3 HR for the AA’s STL.

-  #1  Click for the Tip O’Neill  Award.

-  #2  However, that was in 1887 when walks were tabulated as hits.  Adjusted to today’s standard, he still hit .435, 2nd highest all-time (see Monday’s question).

FCR -  Tom Willoughby, Elkridge, Maryland

Incorrect guesses:  Jack Graney, Ross Barnes, Dan Brouthers,

 

 

WEEKEND BONUS  — 10-Aug

Q.  Who was the first player to homer in five consecutive games?

Hint: #1  In the course of his career he played every position on the diamond.

Hint: #2  He did Mickey Mantle one better.

A.  HARDY RICHARDSON  [Wiki Bio]

-  Ans.  Richardson went deep in each of the G on 10-, 11-, 12-, 15- & 15-Jul-1890 playing for the Players League Boston Reds.  This was again brought the public’s attention when Richardson’s feat was tied by Babe Ruth 10-14-Jun-1920, 30 years later.

-  #1  He caught 6 X and even pitched 5 X.

-  #2  Richardson’s career BA was .299.  Mantle’s was .298.

FCR -  ¯\_()_/¯

Incorrect guesses:  Cesar Tovar, Jimmie Foxx, Delahanty, Harry Wright, Bert Campaneris

 

 

SUNDAY  — 11-Aug

Q.  Which player became a noted surgeon, practicing at the Mayo Clinic, among other hospitals?

Hint: #1  He sued the St. Louis franchise owner for false arrest after being held overnight on a complaint filed by that same owner.

Hint: #2  His nickname was “I am loyal”.

A.  MARK BALDWIN  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  He quit baseball at age 29 to pursue his childhood dream of becoming a doctor & studied at Johns Hopkins & Belville Medical College.

-  #1  St. Louis Browns owner Chris Von Der Ahe, a gentleman of questionable repute at the best of times, had Baldwin arrested for conspiring w/O'Neil to sign players from St. Louis to Pittsburgh shortly thereafter.  The charges were dropped & Baldwin sued von der Ahe for false imprisonment. After years of litigation, Baldwin won a judgement of $2,525 (equivalent to $92,000 in 2023) against him in 1897.

-  #2  His nickname, “Fido”, literally means “I am loyal” or merely “faithful” in Latin.

FCR -  ¯\_()_/¯

Incorrect guesses:  Bobby Brown, Jimmy Howick

 

 

WEEK’S FINALE  — 11-Aug

Q.  Which pitcher won his league’s Win-Loss% title in his one full year in the majors?

Hint: #1  He played in three major leagues without changing his city.

Hint: #2  He never owned a major league team.

A.  BILL DALEY  [Wiki Bio]

-  Ans.  Daley had a record of 3-3 in his brief time w/Boston in the NL in 1889.  He

-  #1  In 1889, he played with the Boston Beaneaters who finished 2nd in the NL.  In 1990, he had his best year, playing for the Boston Reds of the PL.  In 1991, his team was The Boston Reds of the AA.

-  #2  His namesake, William R. Daley was a businessman & owned two AL franchises.  He owned the Cleveland Indians, 1956–1962 & was co-owner of the Seattle Pilots, 1969.

FCR -  John Ford, Greenwich, Connecticut

Incorrect guesses:  Jocko Flynn

     

 

 

WEEK’S THEME – Statistical Leaders for the 1890 Players’ League.*  Opposed to baseball's reserve clause & a growing movement led by Albert Spalding to cap players' salaries, John Montgomery Ward & other players in 1885 formed the first players’ union in baseball—the Brotherhood of Professional Base Ball Players.

 

                                    These are therefore the one-season & career leaders of the Players’ League*.

 

* The apostrophe is mine.  Sorry.  I can’t help myself.

 

Leader                       Stat          #             Team        Career WAR

Baldwin

................................... W.......... 33........... CHI................... 19.3

................................... G........... 58

................................... CG........ 53

 

BECKLEY................. 3B......... 22.......... PLP.................. 61.2

 

BROUTHERS............ OGP... .466......... BOS................. 78.7

 

Browning.................. BA....... .373......... CLE.................. 40.4

................................... 2B......... 40

 

CONNOR................... SLG.... .548......... NYI................... 84.3

................................... OPS.... .998

 

Daley......................... W%..... .720......... BOS................... 1.9

 

DUFFY....................... R......... 161......... NYI................... 43.1

................................... H......... 191

................................... G......... 137*

 

King........................... WAR... 12.4......... CHI................... 50.4

................................... ERA.... 2.69

................................... ERA+.. 162

................................... GS........ 56

................................... SHO...... 4

 

O’Neill........................ G......... 137*........ CHI................... 25.4

 

Richardson............... HR........ 16.......... BOS................. 41.0

................................... RBI...... 152

................................... TB....... 291

 

Stovey....................... SB........ 97.......... BOS................. 41.0

 

ALL CAPS = HOF

 

 

First Correct Respondent identifying themeWarren Kent III, Whitehall, Michigan (After O’Neill)

 

 

Incorrect theme guesses:

 

Mon     -  Boston players that have tied for an RBI title

 

Tues    -  Players inducted to HOF in 1945

-   HOFers to play in the Players League

-   HOFers that were born in 19th century and played at one time or another for Phillies

-   Players with 100 or more home runs in 19th century

-   First players to hit 100 career home runs

 

Wed     -  Linear All-time HR Champions

-   Played for a 19th century “world series” winner

 

Thur     -  Highest career WAR for players who played in the Players League

 

Sat       -  19th century leaders in WAR

 

If you know someone who would enjoy receiving daily Horsehide Trivia questions, they need only drop an email request to horsehidetrivia@aol.com.

 

Click here => FULL WEEK to see this week’s quiz, compete with questions, answers and even the incorrect guesses.

 

Scroll back to see previous Horsehide Trivia posts as far back as 2010.  Quizzes before that may also be available upon request.

 

 

Horsehide Trivia encourages independent research.  ⚾️

No comments:

Post a Comment