Monday, July 20, 2026

2026-07-13 American League MVP candidates who were runners-up twice and never won the award.

MONDAY  — 13-Jul-2026

Q.  Whose career 1.82 ERA is the best all-time?

Hint: #1  The season he threw 464 innings, he led the league in WAR.

Hint: #2  The year his team won their first World Series, he was tied for third on the team for home runs hit.

A.  ED WALSH  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  Walsh pitched for 17 seasons, all of them in the Deadball Era.  His ERA of 1.816 is probably safe for a while.

-  #1  Walsh’s 464 innings pitched in 1908 is the most ever in a season in the Modern Era (1900- ).  His pitching WAR that year was 10.3, best in the AL.  [NYG’s Mathewson posted a 11.8 pitching WAR the same season.]

-  #2  The 1906 White Sox, “The Hitless Wonders”, beat the talented cross-town Cubs 4—2 in the 1st WS for both teams.  Howsomever, evidence shows that Walsh, who homered in both 1907 & 1908 tried to push one of those round-trippers BACK into the 1906 stats to make it look like he had done it in a WS-winning year.  AHA…  Ed we caught ya!

FCR – Cliff Beiser, Kissimmee, Florida

Incorrect guesses:  Walter Johnson, Addie Joss, Babe Ruth, Old Hoss Radbourne, Christy Matthewson

 

 

TUESDAY  — 14-Jul-2026

Q.  Which former Angels slugger is the last player to lead the majors in runs-batted-in for three straight seasons?

Hint: #1  He was a two-time California all-state baseball player but he also made all-state teams in football and basketball.

Hint: #2  Descriptions of him by press writers varied among “ovate”, “pyknic”, “orotund” & “endomorphic” but also “colossal”, “towering” & “dominant”.

Hint: #3  His grandson was signed by the Brewers in July 2024.

A.  CECIL FIELDER  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  In 1990, 1991 & 1992, Fielder had 132, 133 & 124 RBI respectively.  The last player to do it before him was Babe Ruth in 1919-1921.  He played for ANA in 1998.

-  #1  Attending Nogales HS (La Puente, CA), Fielder obviously had choices to make but chose baseball and signed with KCR.

-  #2  Even if occasionally oxymoronic, all seem to fit.

-  #3  Fielder’s grandson, Jadyn Fielder, Prince Fielder's son, was signed by the MIL as an undrafted free agent in July 2024 after being bypassed in the 2024 amateur draft.

FCR -  Andrew Milner, Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania

Incorrect guesses:  Ted Kluszewski, Don Baylor, Reggie Jackson, Dave Winfield, George Foster

 

 

WEDNESDAY  — 15-Jul-2026

Q.  Among Hall of Famers born in Maryland who played the most seasons for only one team?

Hint: #1  He was the first post-WWII American League player to hit two home runs in one inning.

Hint: #2  It’s a shame he never pitched in the majors… he would have been a great part of any battery.

A.  AL KALINE  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  Kaline was born in Baltimore and spent all 22 of his major league seasons with the Tigers.

-  #1  On 17-Apr-1955, Kaline went deep in the 6th inning off 2 Bobs, Spicer & Trice.  Because he had homered earlier in the 3rd inning, he became on the 5th Tiger ever with 3 HRs in one game.

-  #2  Get it?  [Certified today as a non-Dad joke by reader Jay Herdson of Ellicott City, Maryland.]

FCR -  Bill Rudolph, Collingswood, New Jersey

Incorrect guesses:  Cal Ripken, Jimmie Foxx, Brooks Robinson

 

 

THURSDAY  — 16-Jul-2026

Q.  Who was the first player to homer from each side of the plate in consecutive games?

Hint: #1  Immediately after winning the Rookie of  the Year Award, he received Most Valuable Player votes in each of the next eight consecutive seasons.

Hint: #2  Of his taciturn approach to the media, one writer penned, “[his] bronze bust in Cooperstown will chatter only slightly less than the man himself.  The first line of text on the monument should read:  He spoke rarely & carried a mighty bat.”

A.  EDDIE MURRAY  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  Murray switch-hit HRs on 08-, 09-May-1987, off White Sox pitchers Jose DeLeon (RHP), Ray Searage (LHP), Joel McKeon (LHP) & Bob James (RHP).

-  #1  AL ROY in 1977.  Got some MVP votes 1978-1985, including five Top 5 finishes.

-  #2  The quote is from Baltimore sportswriter David Ginsburg.  Those closest to Murray, notably Cal Ripken Jr. claimed to know a whole other personality.

FCR -  John McCleod, Marysville, Michigan

Incorrect guesses:  Johnny Bench, Mickey Mantle, Chipper Jones

 

 

FRIDAY  — 17-Jul-2026

Q.  Who was the last player with one hundred twenty-five runs batted in while hitting fewer than ten home runs that same season?

Hint: #1  He is the only American League shortstop with a qualifying batting average above .375 for any season.

Hint: #2  When referring to him, A & P meant more than where he got his groceries.

A.  LUKE APPLING  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  Although it had been done 20 times before he did it, no one has done it since.  Appling posted exactly 6 HR in 1936 w/CHW & had 128 RBI.

-  #1  He hit .388 in 1936 to lead the AL.  That figure would be italicized had Josh Gibson not hit .396 for the Pittsburgh Crawfords in the Negro National League that year.

-  #2  Appling’s best-known nickname was “Old Aches & Pains”.  SABR claims that he was arguably the greatest hypochondriac ever to play the game.  Backaches, headaches, bad knees & eye problems would torment him.  Notwithstanding, he’d have a game with 3 hits without waiting to be pain-free.  A & P was the nation’s largest grocery store chain at the time.

FCR -  Steven Krevisky, Middletown, Connecticut

Incorrect guesses: 

 

 

IN MEMORIAM  — 18-Jul-2026

Q.  Who was the first Met to receive an MVP vote?

Hint: #1  He wore a thick rubber girdle under his uniform.

Hint: #2  In the Modern Era, nobody was ever hit-by-pitch more times in a single year.

Hint: #3  He led the National League in being hit by pitches more seasons than any other player.

Hint: #4  Teammate Bobby Bonds once joked after seeing a giant black bruise on this player’s back.

Hint: #5  Owning his place in the history of the game, he said, “Some people give their bodies to science; I gave mine to baseball.”

A.  RON HUNT  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  Got 1 MVP vote in 1964.  He received 2 more MVP votes in his career, 1969 & 1973, but let’s not use that as a measure of his importance to the game.

-  #1  He claimed it helped “a little”.

-  #2  Hunt was plunked fifty (50!) times in 1971, his1st year with the Expos in just their 3rd year of operation.

-  #3  He led the NL in HBP 7 times:  1968-1974. Playing for SFG, MON  LAD.

-  #4  The senior Bonds advised “Believe me, there's no advantage in turning my color.”

-  #5 On his controversial talent, he confessed, "I worked and practiced in full uniform in a mirror to make sure it was perfect.  I'd stand right on top of the plate.  An inside pitch had to be right on the corner, or it would hit me.  The umpires never called me for getting hit on purpose."  Someone once said, “He gets good flesh on the ball.”

FCR -  Firefighter Barry Nelson, Guilderland New York

Incorrect guesses:  Craig Biggio

 

SATURDAY  — 18-Jul-2026

Q.  Which former Kanas City A’s player was six feet tall at age eleven and carried his birth certificate with him to show to doubting adults, particularly coaches of young baseball teams?

Hint: #1  The first time he was an All-Star, his team won their first World Series in more than forty years.

Hint: #2  He also led the team in WAR that season, a team that could itself claim four future Hall of Famers.

A.  JOE RUDI  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  Rudi eventually topped out at 6'2", watching many of his classmates catch up to him.

-  #1  His A’s  won their first of 3 straight WS in 1972, the first time the franchise had taken the top spot since the Hall-of-Fame laden squad of 1930 when Mickey Cochrane, Eddie Collins, Lefty Grove, Jimmie Foxx & Al Simmons were on the payroll.

-  #2  The 1972 A’s had Reggie Jackson, Rollie Fingers, Catfish Hunter & Orlando Cepeda (who only played 3 games for them in July).

FCR -  Andrew Milner, Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania

Incorrect guesses:  Eric Hosmer, John Mayberry

 

 

SUNDAY  — 19-Jul-2026

Q.  Who was the first Rookie of the Year to lead his league in runs, doubles and batting average and to lead the majors in hits and total bases, all in his rookie season?

Hint: #1  It would be another twenty-two years before another native of his country would win another Rookie of the Year Award.

Hint: #2  He was denied becoming the first unanimous American League Rookie of the Year by a single first-place vote cast for a nineteen-year-old nineteen-game winning pitcher.

A.  TONY OLIVA  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  Oliva’s monster rookie season included 109 runs, 217 hits, 43 doubles, .323 batting average & 374 total bases.

-  #1  The next Cuban to be ROY in either league was Jose Canseco in 1986.  Since then Jose Fernandez (2013), Jose Abreu (2014*), Yordan Alvarez (2019*) & Randy Arozarena (2021) have been the ROY in their league.

-  #2  First-place votes for AL ROY in 1964:  Oliva 19, BAL’s Wally Bunker 1.

*Unanimous

FCR -  David Kaiser, Watertown, Massachusetts

Incorrect guesses:  Orlando Cepeda

 

 

THEME:  American League MVP candidates who were runners-up twice and never won the award.  Theme suggestion and research done by Bill Deane, Cooperstown

 

Player Club (LEA.)      YEAR      MVP Winner            Club         WAR

2. Appling CHI (AL)     1936         Lou Gehrig               NYY          77.4

                                      1943         Spud Chandler         NYY

 

7. Fielder DET (AL)     1990         Rickey Henderson   OAK         17.2

                                      1991         Cal Ripken               BAL

 

3. Kaline DET (AL)      1955         Yogi Berra                NYY          92.8

                                      1963         Elston Howard         NYY

 

6. Murray BAL (AL)      1982         Robin Yount             MIL           68.7

                                      1983         Cal Ripken               BAL

 

4. Oliva MIN (AL)         1965         Zoilo Versalles         MIN          43.0

                                      1970         Boog Powell             BAL

 

5. Rudi OAK (AL)         1972         Dick Allen                 CHW        25.5

                                      1974         Jeff Burroughs          TEX

 

1. Walsh CHI (AL)        1911         Ty Cobb                    DET          66.5

                                      1912         Tris Speaker             BOS


First Correct Respondent identifying theme – Rick Fink, Edison, New Jersey

 

 

Incorrect theme guesses:

 

Tues    -  Fathers & sons who played for same franchise

 

Wed     -  Players who had a son play for the same MLB team as they did

 

Fri        -  Hall of Famers who led the league in WAR but never won MVP

 

If you know someone who would enjoy receiving daily Horsehide Trivia questions, have them click here:  Horsehide Trivia or do it on their behalf.

 

Click here => THIS WEEK’s quiz, compete with questions, hints, answers & even incorrect guesses.

 

Scroll back to see previous Horsehide Trivia posts as far back as 2010.  Quizzes before that may also be available upon request.

 

 

Horsehide Trivia encourages independent research.  ⚾️

No comments:

Post a Comment