Monday, November 16, 2026

2026-11-09 Nineteenth century Double-Unique players* (with positive career WAR)

MONDAY  — 9-Nov-2026

Q.  Which Hall of Famer still holds the career record for putouts among second basemen?

Hint: #1  He led the league in home runs one year, then led in triples the next with a total that more than doubled his league-leading home run total of the year before.

Hint: #2  He also holds the record, which is still intact after 140 seasons, for most putouts in one season, which coincidentally, meant for him…140 games (1,239 innings).

A.  BID McPHEE  [SABR Bio]










-  Ans. His putout total of 6,552 is now virtually untouchable.  The current leader is Jose Altuve with 2,737.  McPhee was called by many the greatest second baseman of the nineteenth century.  Nevertheless, it was a century before he was invited to Cooperstown.

-  #1   In 1886, playing for Cincinnati in the American Association, all it took to lead the league was 8 HR.  In 1887, he only hit 2 HR, but one of them opening a reverse natural cycle against Baltimore on 26-Aug-1887.  He did, however, hit 19 3B, tops in the circuit.

-  #2  McPhee had 529 putouts in 1886.  In second place all-time is Bobby Grich with 484, but in 200 more innings.  The most by any current active leader is a tied between Altuve in 2013 & Ozzie Albies in 2019.  They each had 273

FCR -  Jim Copeland, Metairie, Louisiana

Incorrect guesses:  Nap Lajoie, Eddie Collins, Ryne Sandberg,  Rogers Hornsby, Joe Morgan, Frankie Frisch, Nellie Fox

 

 

TUESDAY — 10-Nov-2026

Q.  Who tied the Modern Era record for putouts by a left fielder in a nine-inning game, with eleven?

Hint: #1  His nose was broken during pre-game batting practice before collecting his team's first hit.

Hint: #2  In one of his best seasons, he led the majors in runs and stolen bases.

Hint: #3  He tied the record for most times in a season than any other American League player in the Deadball Era.

A.  TOPSY HARTSEL  [SABR Bio]









-  Ans.  Record of 11 was set on  10-Sep-1901, against the Brooklyn Superbas.  This tied the mark of Dick Harley who recorded 11 PO in LF for St. Louis on 30-Jun-1898.  Paul Lehner & Willie Horton later matched the mark.

-  #1  After the scuffle & with an impaired proboscis, Hartsel singled against NYY’s Slow Joe Doyle.

-  #2  In 1902, Playing for PHA, he scored 109 times and stole 47 bases.  He also led his own league with 87 BB.  Dave Fultz had scored 109 runs for PHA in 1902.  Sammy Strang scored 108 in the American League and 1 in the National League, both in 1902.

-  #3  In 1905, his 121 BB was the best of the Era & set the AL record that stood until Babe Ruth drew 150 in 1920.

FCR -  Mike Kositch, Portland, Oregon

Incorrect guesses:  Joe Jackson

 

 

WEDNESDAY  — 11-Nov-2026

Q.  Who is the only pitcher to hit three triples in one major league game?

Hint: #1  He was the slightly less famous part of a dynamic pitching duo who dominated the National League

Hint: #2  He is one of the pitchers referenced who speed was so great that it was decided that the pitching distance needed to be lengthened.

A.  JOUET MEEKIN   [SABR Bio]










Ans. -  In Cleveland on Wednesday, 04-Jul-1894(2), Meekin hit 3 3B off Nig Cuppy, helping the Giants beat the Spiders 11-12.  And he had a little assistance that day as long balls hit into the overflow outfield crowd went for three bases.  The Independence Day crowd was naturally larger than usual.  Three triples were accomplished more frequently in those days – a couple of players even hit four triples in a game prior to 1900.

-  #1  Meekin teamed with Hall of Famer-to-be Amos Rusie that gave NYG a one-two punch to start every series.  In 1894, Meekin won 33 games & Rusie won 36 for NYG.

 

-  #2  SABR’s Rob Neyer cited Meekin, Amos Rusie & Cy Young among the hard throwers who spurred the move to 60 feet, 6 inches in 1893, the old distance of 45 feet now untenable for batters.

FCR -  Brian Barris, Oneida, New York

Incorrect guesses:  Mickey Welch, Kid Nichols, Amos Rusie, Don Newcombe, Bob Caruthers, Don Drysdale, Johnny Sain

 

 

MIDWEEK BONUS  12-Nov-2026

Q.  Whose 0.9 WAR shared his team’s lead in his major league team one year?

Hint: #1  He played on some very good teams as well ,often with some Hall-of-Fame-bound teammates such as Honus Wagner, Cy Young and Ed Walsh.

Hint: #2  He was a battery mate of the mercurial Hall of Famer to be, Rube Waddell.

Hint: #3  He only played in one World Series, but managed to get a double off Christy Mathewson.

A.  OSSEE SCHRECONGOST  [SABR Bio]










-  Ans.  Schrecongost shared the execrable Cleveland Spiders’ top spot with another catcher at 0.9.  The team’s final win-loss record was 20-143 or .130%.  Read more here & here.

-  #1  The other HOF teammates he had were Fred Clarke, Jesse Burkett, Bobby Wallace, Jimmy Collins, Addie Joss, Elmer Flick, Eddie Plank, Charles Bender, Home Run Baker & Eddie Collins.

-  #2  Waddell was well-known for his quirks, but he was allowed to select his battery mate.  On the road, they were roommates as well.

-  #3  The 1905 World Series was an important stake, establishing the format that has endured to this day.

FCR -  DeLodovico, Rockville, Maryland

Incorrect guesses:  Chief Meyers, Jack Lapp, George Whitted

 

 

THURSDAY  — 12-Nov -2026

Q.  Which long-time Detroit pitcher had a career where he finished 277 of the 292 games he started?

Hint: #1  He was the first German-born regular player in the National League.

Hint: #2  His nickname came from the path his most famous pitch supposedly took.

A.  PRETZELS GETZIEN  [SABR Bio]










-  Ans.  Getzien played for the  Detroit Wolverines for the first 5 of his 9 years in the majors.

-  #1  He was born in Prussia (modern Germany) in1864.

-  #2  Getzien’s pitch took a path that twisted in the shape of a pretzel on its way to the plate.  According to Sporting Life, batters described the pitch as a “pretzel curve”.

FCR -  Barry Nelson, Guilderland, New York

Incorrect guesses:  Hal Newhouser, Hooks Dauss, Lady Baldwin, Hooks Wiltse, Rip Sewell, Johnny Sain, Johnny Sain, Jim Tobin

 

 

FRIDAY  — 13-Nov-2026

Q.  Who holds the record for most wins in a single season by a BLTR pitcher for the Boston/Milwaukee/Atlanta Braves in the Modern Era?

Hint: #1  Surprisingly, the following season, he led the National League in five negative pitching categories.

Hint: #2  The year he had the highest total WAR on his team, they lost ninety-eight games and had the lowest attendance in the National League.

A.  TOGIE PITTINGER  [SABR Bio]









-  Ans.  Pittinger’s 27 wins in 1902 ties the win total of his BRTR teammate ,Vic Willis, that same year.  No pitcher on the Braves has since reached that level.

-  #1  A leader in losses (22), earned runs allowed (136), hits allowed (396), home runs allowed (12) & walks allowed (143), all in part because he worked 351⅔ innings to accomplish all that.

-  #2  In 1904, Pittinger’s 3.3 WAR led Boston’s NL team.  He had a 4.5 in pitching WAR that year too.  The team struggled partially because the new American League franchise across town was not only doing well, but were AL Champs that season.

FCR -  Ed Yoder, Port Matilda, Pennsylvania

Incorrect guesses:  John Clarkson, Vic Willis, Kid Nichols, Phil Niekro

 

 

SATURDAY  — 14-Nov-2026

Q.  Which pitcher needed three teams and 394⅔ innings to lead the league in losses and Wild Pitches and all in his first complete season in the majors?

Hint: #1  That year’s performance resulted in the worst single-season WAR in major league history.

Hint: #2  In a three year period, he played on three different major league teams all in the same city, but all in different leagues.

A.  JERSEY BAKLEY  [SABR Bio]

 -  Ans.  Bakley played for (all in the Union Association) The Philadelphia Knights (30 games); The Wilmington Quicksteps (2 games); & the Kansas City Cowboys (5 games).

-  #1  His -5.3 in 1884 is the single worst WAR ever recorded—for a player of any position.  It was -5.5 w/PHK, but he inched up a little with w/WIL & KCC where he finished just ahead of Peek-a-Boo Veach.  No other pitcher or position has ever sunk below the -5.0 barrier.

-  #2     In 1888, Bakley played for the Cleveland Blues of the American Association;

in 1989, the Cleveland Spiders of the National League where he led the team in WAR; &

in 1890, The Cleveland Infants of the Players League.  [Note that he led the Spiders in WAR & was 2nd in WAR on the Blues.]

FCR -  Terry Walter, Wabasha, Minnesota

Incorrect guesses:  Dave Davenport 

 

 

SUNDAY  — 15-Nov-2026

Q.  After his debut season in the majors, which pitcher repeatedly refused offers from the team for six straight years?

Hint: #1  Three amateur teammates of his became his brothers-in-law.

Hint: #2  Once signed, his Hall of Fame manager said, “I have been trying to get him for the Giants for the last two years, and he is not only a good pitcher, but he is a clever batsman and baserunner.”

A.  HUYLER WESTERVELT  [SABR Bio]










 

 

 

-  Ans.  After Westervelt pitched for the New York Giants player in 1894, new owner Andrew Freedman offered him a pay cut for 1895.  Westervelt sent the contract back unsigned, then kept turning down low offers while the Giants held him on their reserve list through 1901.  He never pitched in the majors again.

-  #1  His New Jersey Athletic Club teammates were catcher Walter Currie, second baseman, Joe Currie & pitcher William “Doc” Currie.  Westervelt married their younger sister Gertrude from Bayonne, New Jersey, in October 1896.  The couple remained married for 53 years and had a daughter named Madelon in 1900.

-  #2  -NYG player/manager John Montgomery Ward praised his newest player, but nobody was thrilled with the season that followed.  Westervelt went 7–10 with a 5.04 ERA.  In his final major league game, he went the distance in a 20–1 loss at Baltimore.

FCR -  Randall Chandler, Germantown, Tennessee

Incorrect guesses:  Horace “Hod” Lisenbee, Wes Ferrell

 

 

MIDMONTH BONUS  — 15-Nov-2026

Q.  Which standout first baseman returned to the major leagues by being a minor league team that was adopted and absorbed by a newly-formed major league?

Hint: #1  He was the ninth ever major leaguer to hit for the cycle.

Hint: #2  After baseball, he was a police patrol when he was killed in the line of duty.

A.  MOX McQUERY  [SABR Bio]










-  Ans.  McQuery was team captain for minor league Syracuse Stars of the American Association in 1890.  When the AA raised the Stars franchise to major league level, it put Mox McQuery back in the major leagues for the first time in four years.

-  #1  He cycled on 28-Sep-1885 in a 14-2 win over Providence.

-  #2  McQuery was a patrol officer for the Covington Police Department when he was killed.  He had stopped a horse-drawn streetcar that contained 2 men wanted for murder.  He ordered them off the car, & in the ensuing shootout Wallace Bishop fatally shot him in the chest.

FCR -  Windsor Morgan, Baltimore, Maryland

Incorrect guesses:  Bob Meusel

 

 

WEEK’S FINALE  — 15-Nov-2026

Q.  Who is the only person who debuted in 1871, whose first name AND last name have not once shared by any of the 23,600+ major leaguers who have followed him?

Hint: #1  The only better player on his team was Cap Anson, but it was this player who led the team in triples, home runs, runs batted in and slugging.

Hint: #2  He had been a local home run hero before turning professional.  His career came to a much-too-soon close thanks, it is said, to Mrs. O’Leary’s cow.

A.  GAT STIRES  [SABR Bio]










-  Ans.  Stires first game was on 06-May-1871, playing for the Rockford Forest Citys of the new, professional National Association.   Baseball-Reference identifies him as the 38th major leaguer ever.

-  #1  He had 6 3B, 2 HR, 24 RBI and slugged .473 in 25 games.

-  #2  The Great Chicago Fire in the fall of 1871 was purposely mythologized as a cow kicking over a lit lantern to begin the blaze.  Without a Chicago team, the league had to disband.  They picked it up again in the spring of 1872.

FCR -  Mark Kozlevcar, El Segundo, California

Incorrect guesses:  Lip Pike, Nate Berkenstock, Levi Meyerli, Fred Treacy

 

 

THEME:  Nineteenth century Double-Unique players* (with positive career WAR)

 

As we know him                Debut                     Full name                     WAR

Bakley............................. 11-May-1883....... Edward Enoch Bakley..................... 1.1

 

Getzien............................ 13-Aug-1884........ Charles H. Getzien........................ 18.0

 

Hartsel............................. 14-Sep-1898........ Tully Frederick Hartsel................... 31.2

 

McPhee........................... 2-May-1882......... John Alexander McPhee............... 52.5

 

McQuery......................... 20-Aug-1884........ William Thomas McQuery............... 5.6

 

Meekin............................. 13-Jun-1891......... George Jouett Meekin................... 27.8

 

Pittinger.......................... 26-Apr-1900......... Charles Reno Pittinger.................. 14.0

 

Schrecongost................. 8-Sep-1897.......... Freeman Osee Schrecongost....... 12.3

 

Stires............................... 6-May-1871......... Garret C. Stires................................ 0.5

 

Westervelt....................... 21-Apr-1894......... Huyler Westervelt............................ 0.4

 

*Please send updates or corrections

 

First Correct Respondent identifying theme – Michael McCroskey, Sugar Land, Texas (after Getzien on Thursday)

 

 

Incorrect theme guesses:

 

  Mon      -  Players who have accomplished a reverse natural cycle

 

  

  Wed      -  Baseball players from the late 19th and early 20th centuries who went by distinctive nicknames instead of their given first names

-       Baseball players from the late 19th and early 20th centuries who went by distinctive nicknames instead of their given first names, which are the same as another MLB players' last name

 

   Thu       -  Late 19th Century and early 20th century players in rule and equipment evolution

-       MLB Double Uniques

 

Fri     -     players with “double unique” names

-       Greatest nicknames

 

Sun   -     Double-uniques who played the most games

 

 

If you know someone who would enjoy receiving daily Horsehide Trivia questions, have them click here:  Horsehide Trivia or do it on their behalf.

 

Click here => THIS WEEK’s quiz, compete with questions, hints, answers & even incorrect guesses.

 

Scroll back to see previous Horsehide Trivia posts as far back as 2010.  Quizzes before that may also be available upon request.

 

 

Horsehide Trivia encourages independent research.  ⚾️

No comments:

Post a Comment