Monday, March 17, 2025

2025-03-10 Players who hit forty home runs in a season but were not All-Stars that year

MONDAY  — 10-Mar-2025

Q.  Which player had a candy bar bearing his nickname sold during the 2006 season?

Hint: #1  He tied an icon’s iconic record then signed on with that icon’s former team.

Hint: #2  His nickname was “Pronk”, really.

A.  TRAVIS HAFNER  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  The bar was sold primarily in and around Cleveland during Hafner’s career year.

-  #1  In 1987 the Yankees’ Don Mattingly hit 6 grand slams to break the record tie that Ernie Banks (1955) and Jim Gentile (1961) held.  Hafner hit 6 of ‘em in 2006 and played for NYY at the end of his career. Richie Sexson (2006) & Albert Pujols (2009) have pulled up into a tie with Banks and Gentile.

-  #2  “Pronk” is a combination of the words "project" and "donkey" given to him by a teammate inspired by Hafner’s running style.

FCR -  Jason Winston, Riverside, California

Incorrect guesses:  Reggie Jackson

 

 

TUESDAY  — 11-Mar-2025

Q.  Who was the first batter to drive in more than one hundred and forty runs in his rookie season?

Hint: #1  He was the first player to steal a base after the fifteenth inning of a game in the American League.

Hint: #2  Don’t be tricked into thinking of him as a native Scandinavian.

A.  HAL TROSKY  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  Trosky had 142 RBI in 1934.

-  #1  SB on 11-May-1944 in the 16th inning.  HOWEVER… a fine team of researchers recently discovered that this was done much earlier by Hall of Famer Harry Hooper.  He stole 3rd then scored the winning run in the 16th inning on 16-Aug-1916(1).  We thank them for the update.

-  #2  Trosky was born in Norway, Iowa.

FCR -  Tom Hablitzel, Hudson, Ohio

Incorrect guesses:  Ted Williams, Joe DiMaggio, Swede Risberg, Walt Dropo

 

 

WEDNESDAY  — 12-Mar-2025

Q.  Which one-time Texas Ranger ended four consecutive seasons with the identical batting average?

Hint: #1  He played on a powerhouse college baseball team.

Hint: #2  He hit a home run on Opening Day in three consecutive seasons.

A.  KHRIS DAVIS  [B-R Bio]

-  Ans.

TEAM:

MIL

OAK

OAK

OAK

YEAR:

2015

2016

2017

2018

H:

97

137

140

142

AB:

392

555

566

576

AVG:

.247

.247

.247

.247

     He played for TEX in his last season, 2021.

-  #1  Played for Cal State Fullerton, NCAA D-1 champs in 1979, 1984, 1995, 2004 and were runners-up in 1992.  Davis missed those years with them but knew what a strong program they had.

-  #2  He hit 3 OD HRs = 2017, 2018, 2019.

FCR -  Mary Hums, Louisville

Incorrect guesses:  Will Clark, Michael Young, Albert Belle, Pete Incaviglia, Kenny Lofton, Adrian Beltre, Pete O’Brien

 

 

THURSDAY  — 12-Mar-2025

Q.  Which paragon of “Three True Outcomes” grew up playing baseball with ROY/MVP/batting champ Kris Bryant?

Hint: #1  This Gold Glover can claim the eighth-longest home run in the Statcast era.

Hint: #2  In High School, he threw a no-hitter in the afternoon then took a certain Hall of Famer's daughter to the prom the same night.

A.  JOEY GALLO  [B-R Bio]

-  Ans.  Bryant & Gallo grew up playing with and against each other in Las Vegas.  The remain friends to this day.  3 True Outcomes (TTO) are the results of a plate appearance that do not involve the defense, i.e., a Home Run, a Base on Balls or a Strikeout

-  #1  Gallo’s 2nd HR on 20-Jul-2018 in his home ball park in Arlington, travelled a nifty 495’.  Watch both here.  Gallo won AL OF gold Gloves in 2020 & 2021.

-  #2  On 14-Apr-2012, Gallo, then 17 & a senior at Bishop Gorman HS in Las Vegas, pitched a no-hitter against Gloucester Catholic.  That evening, he attended prom with Paige Maddux, daughter of pitcher Greg Maddux.  (Maddux calls it one of Gallo’s earliest strikeouts.)

FCR -  Evan Thompson, Mesa

Incorrect guesses:  Aaron Judge, Bryce Harper

 

 

FRIDAY  — 14-Mar-2025

Q.  Which right fielder once threw out Hall of Fame base runners Warren Spahn and Hank Aaron in the same game?

Hint: #1  He hit the Budweiser sign on top of the Busch Stadium scoreboard with a line drive that some estimate could have traveled as much as 600 feet.

Hint: #2  He hit the first home run ever hit in Dodger Stadium.

A.  WALLY POST  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  In a game on 11-Aug-1956, Post threw out Warren Spahn in the 2nd inning & Hank Aaron in the 7th.

-  #1  Long HR on 14-Apr-1961.

-  #2  1st HR in Dodger Stadium = 10-Apr-1962, the only 1 hit in that G.

FCR -  Jim Casey, Savannah

Incorrect guesses:  Willie Stargell, Willie McCovey, Frank Robinson, Carl Furillo, Wally Moon, Mike Shannon, Frank Howard, Lou Brock

 

 

SATURDAY  — 15-Mar-2025

Q.  Who is the only batter to lead the majors in strikeouts in three straight seasons with a total each year exceeding two hundred?

Hint: #1  A ten runs-batted-in game is a notable stop on his baseball résumé.

Hint: #2  In high school, he was a four-year letterman in baseball, basketball and golf.

A.  MARK REYNOLDS  [B-R Bio]

-  Ans.  In Reynolds’ 2nd, 3rd& 4th seasons in the majors, 2008, 2009 & 2010, he struck out 204, 223 & 211 X respectively for BAL.  He came close the next year when he K’d 196 X for BAL.

-  #1  On 07-Jul-2018, he had the G of his life: 5-for-5 with 2 HR & 10 RBIs in a WSN rout of MIA (18-4).  [Note:  No batter has ever struck out 7 rimes in a game.]

-  #2  Attended First Colonial HS, Virginia Beach before attending the University of Virginia in Charlottesville.

FCR -  Jeff Fink, Howell, New Jersey

Incorrect guesses:  Dave Kingman, Reggie Jackson, Kyle Schwarber, Chris Davis, Rob Deer, Adam Dunn

 

 

SUNDAY — 15-Mar-2025

Q.  Which slugger was out of organized baseball one year after leading the league in home runs, with more than forty?

Hint: #1  Twice he had more than two hundred strikeouts in a year, once leading the majors, once his league.

Hint: #2  During his career, his agent was a former World Series MVP.

A.  CHRIS CARTER  [B-R Bio]

-  Ans.  After tying Nolan Arenado in 2016 w/41 HR, Carter was non-tendered by MIL.  He signed w/NYY, but was released after a season with a 0.-8 WAR.

-  #1  Carter led MLB in SB w/212 in 2013, then led the AL w/206 in 2016.

-  #2  Carter’s agent was Dave Stewart, 1989 WS MVP w/OAK.

FCR -  Gregory Koch, Falls Church

Incorrect guesses:  Mark McGuire, Dave Kingman, Adam Dunn, Chris Davis, Khris Davis Albert Belle, Rob Deer

 

 

WEEK’S FINALE  — 16-Mar-2025

Q.  Whose total did the Big Puma pass to move into second place on the franchise’s single-season home run list?

Hint: #1  In a season when he hit .314 with 44 home runs, 122 RBIs and a .636 slugging percentage, he finished a disgraceful twentieth in Most Valuable Player voting.

Hint: #2  Counterintuitively, months earlier, he was shot in the wrist when thugs attempted to hijack his car during a visit home.

Hint: #3  This gentleman may have had noble ancestry.

A.  RICHARD HIDALGO  [MAZ Bio]

-  Ans.  In Houston Aston’s history, only Jeff Bagwell has hit more HR in 1 year (47 in 2000) than did Lance Berkman (45 in 2006) or Hidalgo (44 in 2000).

-  #1  In 2000 WAR wad not yet established, if it had been , Hidalgo’s 6.3 would have placed him tied with Jim Edmonds for 9th in the NL & 7th in the AL.  He did lead the All-Star- & MVP-laden Astros lineup.

-  #2  In November 1999, Hidalgo was the victim of an attempted carjacking in his home country of Venezuela.  Armed assailants attempted to hijack his car, and during the attack, he was shot in the left forearm.  He survived the incident, but the injury had lasting effects on his career.

-  #3  “Hidalgo” was a title of nobility in Spain, denoting a rank of lower nobility (“gentleman” being an adequate translation).  Hidalgo comes from hijo de algo (“son of something”), a person of noble lineage.  Hidalgos seldom held significant land or wealth but were still legally considered part of the noble class and were exempt from some of the taxes and obligations that befell most commoners.

FCR -  Barry Nelson, Guilderland, New York

Incorrect guesses:  Lance Berkman, Jim Wynn

 

 

 

 

 

WEEK’S THEME –  Each had a forty-home-run season but was not an All-Star that year

 

Name                          Year                HR                WAR

Carter........................ 2016............... 41................... 2.6

 

Davis......................... 2016............... 42................. 10.8

Davis......................... 2017............... 43

Davis......................... 2018............... 48

 

Gallo.......................... 2017............... 41................. 15.4

Gallo.......................... 2018............... 40

 

Hafner........................ 2006............... 42................. 24.8

Hidalgo...................... 2000............... 44................. 19.2

Post........................... 1955............... 40................. 18.1

Reynolds................... 2009............... 44................... 6.8

Trosky....................... 1936............... 42................. 29.8

Only Gallo was an All-Star in another season.

 

First Correct Respondent identifying theme – Warren Kent, Whitehall, Michigan (after Davis)

 

 

Incorrect theme guesses:

 

Mon     -  Most career home runs and no All-Star game appearances

 

Tues    -  Top 10 Cleveland Indians

-   Most home runs by a player born in their US state of birth

 

If you know someone who would enjoy receiving daily Horsehide Trivia questions, they need only drop an email request to horsehidetrivia@aol.com.

 

Click here => THIS WEEK’s quiz, compete with questions, answers and even the incorrect guesses.

 

Scroll back to see previous Horsehide Trivia posts as far back as 2010.  Quizzes before that may also be available upon request.

 

 

Horsehide Trivia encourages independent research.  ⚾️

Monday, March 10, 2025

2025-03-03 Top non--Hall of Fame Double Uniques

MONDAY  — 03-Mar-2025

Q.  Which Cy Young Award winner holds the record for most consecutive scoreless innings pitched?

Hint: #1  He dropped out of college after failing to make the baseball team as a freshman, but later hitchhiked back to school to resume his studies.

Hint: #2  He was named the Most Valuable Player for the League Championship Series for a team in the National League and seven years later, for a team in the American League.

A.  OREL HERSHISER  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  On 28-Sep-1988, Hershiser broke the record set by Don Drysdale 30 years earlier.  Hershiser’s 59 straight scoreless innings bested Drysdale’s mark of 58⅔.       

-  #1  Hershiser is an alum of Bowling Green State University in Ohio.

-  #2  He was the 1988 NLCS MVP for LAD & the 1995 ALCS MVP for CLE.

FCR -  Amar Rehal, Chicago

Incorrect guesses:  Bob Gibson

 

 

TUESDAY  — 04-Mar-2025

Q.  After receiving zero votes for Rookie of the Year, who then led the majors in doubles in each if the next two seasons?

Hint: #1  In each of the next thirteen consecutive seasons, he never hit fewer than twenty doubles.

Hint: #2  He was talked out of a music career by his high school baseball coach.

Hint: #3  Only Brooks Robinson and Maury Wills had more at-bats in the 1960s.

A.  VADA PINSON [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  Rookie in 1958, Pinson had 47 2B in 1959 and 37 in 1960.

-  #1  From 1961 through 1973, Pinson was a trusted doubles supplier.  In 5 of those seasons, he had more than 30.

-  #2  Pinson attended McClymonds High School in Oakland, California, the Alma Mater of Frank Robinson & Curt Flood, among others.  Baseball Coach George Powles was actively involved in youth baseball programs, including the American Legion & Connie Mack leagues, further influencing the careers of young athletes in the Oakland area.

-  #3  MLB AB 1960-69 = Brooks Robinson (6,093), Maury Wills (6,091), Vada Pinson (6,086).

FCR -  Jack Woodiel, Goshen, Indiana

Incorrect guesses:  Pete Rose, Billy Williams, Hank Aaron, Roberto Clemente, Carl Yastrzemski

 

 

WEDNESDAY  — 05-Mar-2025

Q.  Which Californian was the first batter to lead any major league in home runs more than five times?

Hint: #1  The first season when he hit more than ten home runs, he was already thirty-one years old.

Hint: #2  One year he hit fewer than twenty-five home runs yet led the runner-up in his league by more than ten.

A.  GAVY CRAVATH  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  Cravath led the NL in HR 6 X:  1913, 14, 15, 17, 18 & 1919 w/19, 19, 24, 12, 8 & 12 respectively.  He was born (Poway) & raised (Escondido) in SoCal.

-  #1  He was born 23-Mar-1881 and hit 11 HR in 1912.

-  #2  Cravath led the NL in 1915 w/24 HR for the pennant-winning Phillies.  Next was the Cubs’ Cy Williams who hit 13.  The AL leader that season, with an anemic 7, was Braggo Roth (3 for CHW & 4 for CLE).  The closest contender was Hal Chase who hit 17 for the Buffalo Blues of the Federal League.

FCR -  Gave Kinstlinger, Reisterstown, Maryland

Incorrect guesses:  George Davis, Harry Stovey, Ken Williams, Cy Williams

 

 

MIDWEEK BONUS  — 05-Mar-2025

Q.  Which St. Louis Browns pitcher tied for the major league lead in pitching wins the same year he led the majors in home runs surrendered?

Hint: #1  He surrendered the first of Jimmie Foxx’s 534 career home runs.

Hint: #2  Pitching for Toronto, he threw an eleven-inning no-hitter.

Hint: #3  This performance was part of a remarkable AA season, when he also set an International League record for consecutive scoreless innings.

A.  URBAN SHOCKER  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  In 1921, Shocker shared top honors in wins with NYY’s Carl Mays w/27.  That same season, Shocker also tied the A’s Eddie Rommel w/21 HR given up.

-  #1  On 31-May-1927(2), in the 8th inning, Shocker, who started and won the game, suffered a fate that would become very familiar to AL pitchers.

-  #2  On 22-Jul-1916, pitching for the Maple Leafs, Shocker held the Rochester Hustlers hitless in 11 innings at the Bay Street Ball Grounds.

-  #3  In 1916, Shocker pitched 54 consecutive scoreless innings & finished with a 15–3 win-loss record & a 1.31 ERA.

FCR -  Tony Monti, Whitestone, New York

Incorrect guesses:  Bobo Holloman, Joe Bush, Bob Groom

 

 

THURSDAY  — 06-Mar-2025

Q.  Who was the first third baseman to hit thirty home runs in a season in the majors?

Hint: #1  In his twelve years in the majors, he never played for a pennant winner.

Hint: #2  Once, fielding a grounder, he stepped on his own glove, pitched forward and broke his clavicle.

A.  HARLOND CLIFT  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  In 1938, Clift hit 34 HR for SLB.  He played 149 G at 3rd that season & nowhere else.  Mel Ott hit 36 HR that same year, but only 28 of his were hit in games when he played 3rd.  That was the only season Ott could have been called a third baseman.

-  #1  Played w/SLB 1934-43 then 1943-45 w/WSH.

-  #2  This accident happened during a 1931 tryout for SLB.  They signed him anyway.

FCR -  Bob Wells, Chantilly, Virginia

Incorrect guesses:  Pie Traynor, Al Rosen, Ken Williams, Hack Wilson, Bobby Thomson

 

 

FRIDAY  — 07-Mar-2025

Q.  Who was the first Asian player in MLB history to hit for the cycle?

Hint: #1  Just this past season, a certain Dodge designated hitter passed him for most career home runs by an Asian player.

Hint: #2  He became a generous philanthropist in 2020 during the COVID-19 pandemic.

A.  SHIN-SOO CHOO  [B-R Bio]

-  Ans.  Playing for TEX 21-Jul-2015 Choo went 4 for 5, getting all 4 flavors of hits available.

-  #1  Choo ended his MLB career w/218 HR.  Shohei Ohtani hit his 219th career (& 48th of the year) HR on 17-Sep-2024.

-  #2  He donated $1,000 to each of the 190 players in the Texas Rangers’ minor league system who were unable to work due to MLB's shutdown.  He also donated $200,000 to the nonprofit Community Chest of Korea to help the city of Daegu, which was the hardest hit city in Korea during the pandemic.

FCR -  Gregory Koch, Falls Church, Virginia

Incorrect guesses:  Ichiro Suzuki, Hideki Matsui, Dave Roberts, Shohei Ohtani

 

 

T.G.I.F.SPECIAL  — 07-Mar-2025

Q.  Who was the first native of Cuba to receive a Hall of Fame vote?

Hint: #1  He led the league (and the majors) in losses the very season before he led in pitching  victories (27 in 1923).

Hint: #2  Only the excellent strikeout totals of Dazzy Vance kept him from achieving a pitching Triple Crown.

A.  DOLF LUQUE  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  Born in Havana (La Habana), Cuba in 1890, Luque received HOF votes 9 X, only once exceeding 5% of the total votes cast that year (1958).

-  #1  Had 22 L for CIN in 1922 then 27 W for them in 1923.

-  #2  In 1923, Luque led the majors in wins (27) & ERA (1.93) but fellow NLer Vance K’ed 197 to Luque’s 151.

FCR -  Andrew Jett, Waxahachie, Texas

Incorrect guesses:  Luis Tiant

 

 

SATURDAY  — 08-Mar-2025

Q.  Which pitcher once had more than one season with double-digit wins and double-digit saves?

Hint: #1  He was the first pitcher to log twenty saves in a season.

Hint: #2  Thirteen years after his playing career, he lost his non-throwing arm yet continued to participate in old-timers’ games.

A.  FIRPO MARBERRY  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  In 1924, Marberry had 11 W & 15 SV.  On 1926, his record shows 12 W & 22 SV.  It’s important to note that Saves were not an official stat until 1969.

-  #1  See Ans. above

-  #2  Lost his left arm 02-Oct-1949 in a car crash.

FCR -  Jesse Asbury, Norman, Oklahoma

Incorrect guesses:  Roy Face, Jim Konstanty

 

 

 

WEEKEND EXTRA  — 08-Mar-2025

Q.  Who was the first regular short player among of the Tall Tactician’s charges?

Hint: #1  In his breakout year, he led his new league in bases on ball, but also led the major in runs, stolen bases and plate appearances.

Hint: #2  Playing for the Chicago Orphans (Cubs today), he established the record for putouts by a left fielder in a nine-inning game.

A.  TOPSY HARTSEL  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  Hartsel was generously listed at 5'5".  Connie Mack stood at 6'1", keeping in mind that the average U.S. male in 1900 measured 5'7"

-  #1  In 1902, Hartsel’s first year with Connie Mack’s PHA, the diminutive speedster had 109 R, 47 SB, 643 PA in 137 G.  He also walked 87 times.

-  #2  On 10-Sep-1901, Brooklyn’s lefty Jay Hughes, was giving up a of balls hit aloft.  11 went Hartsel’s way in LF for a new record.

FCR -  Gabe Kinstlinger, Reisterstown, Maryland

Incorrect guesses:  Max Flack, Wee Willie Keeler, Lave Cross, Bill Shindle

 

 

SUNDAY  — 09-Mar-2025

Q.  Who holds the Boston Red Sox record for stolen bases in a season?

Hint: #1  Two years later, this Gold Glove, Silver Slugger led the majors in WAR.

Hint: #2  New York Yankee fans and management alike, consider his acquisition the most expensive miscalculation this century.

A.  JACOBY ELLSBURY  [B-R Bio]

-  Ans.  Ellsbury’s 70 SB in 2009 led the majors and is best SB season ever by a BOS player.

-  #1  Ellsbury edged Toronto slugger Jose Bautista with his 8.3 WAR for 2011, highlighted by his world-beating 364 Total Bases.

-  #2  After some stellar work  with BOS, Ellsbury did well in free agency, getting, with the professional assistance of the Boras Corporation, a 7-year contract with more than $20,000,000 per year.  He played for 4 of those years, just not as well as anyone had expected.

FCR -  Jim Casey, Savannah

Incorrect guesses:  Johnny Damon

 

 

WEEK’S THEME – Top-rated non-Hall of Fame Double Uniques:  players who last name has never been duplicated in MLB history AND whose first name has likewise never been matched by any other player on any major league roster… ever.

 

Full list here.  Columns C & D on Tab #2 are still a work in progress.  (Edits gladly accepted.)

 

 

D-U Player                              WAR

Choo.............................................. 34.6

 

Clift................................................ 42.1

 

Cravath.......................................... 33.0

 

Ellsbury......................................... 31.2

 

Hartsel........................................... 31.3

 

Hershiser....................................... 56.0

 

Luque............................................. 48.1

 

Marberry........................................ 30.6

 

Pinson........................................... 54.2

 

Shocker......................................... 58.6

 

 

First Correct Respondent identifying theme – Andrew Milner, Philadelphia (After Shocker on Wed)

 

 

Incorrect theme guesses:

 

Mon     -  Pitchers who were Sports Illustrated’s Athlete of the Year

            -  Players who wore glasses

 

Tues    -  Double uniques to play for the Cleveland Indians

-   Players whose only hits in the World Series were for extra bases

 

If you know someone who would enjoy receiving daily Horsehide Trivia questions, they need only drop an email request to horsehidetrivia@aol.com.

 

Click here => THIS WEEK’s quiz, compete with questions, answers and even the incorrect guesses.

 

Scroll back to see previous Horsehide Trivia posts as far back as 2010.  Quizzes before that may also be available upon request.

 

 

Horsehide Trivia encourages independent research.  ⚾️