Monday, December 16, 2024

2024-12-09 Players whose solitary vote spoiled a unanimous vote for the winner of a Cy Young award

MONDAY  — 09-Dec

Q.  Who was the first forty-year-old pitcher to be honored with a Cy Young Award?

Hint: #1  He is the most recent pitcher to have four consecutive three-hundred-inning seasons.

Hint: #2  He wasn’t the first one in his family to win a Cy Young Award.

A.  GAYLORD PERRY  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  NL CYA in 1978 w/SDP, 2 months after he had turned 40

-  #1  300+ innings in: 1972 (342⅔)    w/CLE

1973 (344)       w/CLE

1974 (322⅓)    w/CLE

1975 (305⅔)    w/CLE & TEX

            Perry had led the majors earlier with 325⅓ in 1969 and 328⅔ in 1970 w/SFG.

-  #2  Brother Jim Perry was AL CYA in 1970 w/MIN  .

FCR -  Dennis Walls, Orrington, Maine

Incorrect guesses:  Roger Clemens, Joe Niekro, Phil Niekro, Early Wynn, Justin Verlander

 

 

TUESDAY  — 10-Dec

Q.  Which Cy Young Award winner began his career with a record 29 scoreless innings?

Hint: #1  He was the only pitcher to appear in All-Star games in the 1970s, 1980s and 1990s.

Hint: #2  He is the first pitcher to have one hundred complete games and one hundred saves.

A.  DENNIS ECKERSLEY  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  Between his MLB debut w/CLE on 12-Apr-1975 & 31-May-1975, Eckersley made 11½ appearances without allowing a single ER.

-  #1  He played in the ASG in 1977, 1982,1988, 1990, 1991 & 1992.

-  #2  He ended with 390 Saves & exactly 100 Complete Games.

FCR -  Michael Green, Las Vegas

Incorrect guesses:  Dave Righetti, John Smoltz, Rich Gossage, Greg Maddux

 

 

 

IN MEMORIAM  — 10-Dec

Q.  Who was the first player in the Modern Era to have both a four-home-run game and a seven-hit game in his career?

Hint: #1  He was the last twentieth-century American League player to hit four homers in a game.

Hint: #2  He played a full season without a single error, the first qualifying outfielder to do so.

Hint: #3  He was standing on first base when he learned that he was the subject one of the most controversial baseball trades of his generation…

Hint: #4  …and thus became the focus of a “curse”.

Hint: #5  He was the last living participant of the Home Run Derby held at Wrigley Field.

Hint: #6  It was a former teammate who broke up his hitless innings streak.

Hint: #7  He was once suspended for charging into the stands during a game.

Hint: #8  His fine singing voice was another of his talents.

A.  ROCKY COLAVITO  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  4 HR/G for CLE = 10-Jun-1959.  7H/G for DET = 24-Jun-1962

-  #1  HR X 4 = 10-Jun-1959

-  #2  In 1965, Colavito played in 162 G, had 274 chances, zero (0!) errors.

-  #3  On 17-Apr-1960, CLE traded HR champ Colavito to DET for batting champ Harvey Kuenn.

-  #4  When the trade became public, CLE fans were outraged & called it one of the worst in Cleveland sports history, going so far as to say that it cursed the Indians, contributing to or even causing decades of struggles.  He always disavowed he existence of a curse or his possible part in it.

-  #5  Filmed in December 1959 in Los Angeles at the west coast’s Wrigley Field, the series aired in television syndication from 09-Jan to 02-Jul-1960.  It was a precursor to the Home Run Derby held now in conjunction with the annual MLB All-Star Game.  When Willie Mays died in June of 2024, Colavito became its last surviving former participant.

-  #6  MLB coaches knew about his strong arm & used him twice to pitch in live games.  In his 1st outing on 13-Aug-1958(2), he tossed 3 hitless innings in relief of Hoyt Wilhelm.  Then, on 25-Aug-1968(1) at Yankee Stadium, pitching on ten years’ rest, the Bronx native fulfilled a dream with 2⅓ more hitless frames against DET.  After an Al Kaline double, Colavito retired Willie Horton to close the inning.  That also closed his major league pitching career with a spotless 0.00 ERA.

-  #7  During the game on 12-May-1961, Colavito charged into the stands to intervene in a fight between his father and a New York fan, a “drunken bum” in Colavito’s words, who had been harassing Rocky’s wife.  AL President Joe Cronin opted not to fine Colavito, saying: “It wasn’t the right thing for the boy to go up into the stands, but I guess it was natural for him to want to help his father.”

-  #8  He recorded a few songs, showcasing his baritone voice.

FCR -  Floyd Lapp, New City, New York

Incorrect guesses:  Josh Hamilton, Mark Whiten

 

 

WEDNESDAY  — 11-Dec

Q.  Which former Milwaukee pitcher is responsible for the most career wild pitches thrown by any National League pitcher in the Modern Era?

Hint: #1  He is the only pitcher to lead the National League in losses for four (4!) consecutive seasons.

Hint: #2  He was the first player elected to the Hall of Fame who played for the Toronto Blue Jays.

A.  PHIL NIEKRO  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  Had 200 WP 1964-1987.  Played for MLN in 1964-65.  MLN became ATL in 1966.

-  #1  Led in Ls = 1977-1980 w/20, 18, 20, 18 respectively.

-  #2  HOF in 1997; Played for TOR in 1987.

FCR -  Jerry Kahn, New York City

Incorrect guesses: 

 

 

MIDWEEK BONUS  — 11-Dec

Q.  Who is the only player drafted No. 1 overall by a National League team to win a Cy Young Award?

Hint: #1  It was his second time being drafted in the First Round.

Hint: #2  His brother-in-law once led the majors in triples.

A.  GERRIT COLE  [B-R Bio]

-  Ans.  Drafted #1 by PIT in 2011. Unanimous CYA w/NYY in 2023.

-  #1  Cole was drafted in 2008, Round One, 28th overall by NYY, but chose to attend UCLA and play baseball for the Bruins.

-  #2  Brandon Crawford, a 3 X AS & 4 X GG, in addition to winning WS rings w/SFG in 2012 & 2014, led MLB in 3B w/11 in 2016.  His sister, Amy Crawford is now Mrs. Cole.

FCR -  Rich Lerner, Silver Spring, Maryland

Incorrect guesses:  Tom Seaver, Blake Snell, Steven Strasburg

 

 

THURSDAY  — 12-Dec

Q.  Which towhead was the first left-handed pitcher to win two hundred career games without ever winning twenty games in a season?

Hint: #1  Channeling Max Scherzer, he had a no-hitter that would have been a perfect game except for a fielding error.

Hint: #2  He did a fine Ernie Shore imitation and without an ejection to help him.

A.  JERRY REUSS  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  After 22 seasons in MLB, Reuss had racked up 220 W.  The most in one year, though was 18 in 1975, his best overall career season.

-  #1  Pitching for LAD on 27-Jun-1980,  Reuss had stifled the SFG bats even though he only stuck out 2 and that was weak-hitting C Mike Sadek – twice.  The perfect G possibility was out of the question from the 1st  because of a throwing error by shortstop Bill Russell.  [OK, not exactly like Scherzer’s but you see the comparison.]

-  #2  On 11-Jun-1982, Jerry Reuss recorded 27 consecutive outs in a game, with only the opponent's leadoff batter reaching base (double by Reds' Eddie Milner, who reached third on a sacrifice bunt and scored on a fielder's choice).  Read here about Shore’s game.

FCR -  Mark Hayne, Dumfries, Virginia

Incorrect guesses:  Jamie Moyer, Jon Lester

 

 

FRIDAY  — 13-Dec

Q.  Which National League pitcher, who has four times finished in the top three of Cy Young Award vote recipients, hit the first pitch he saw as a batter, out of the park?

Hint: #1  Once he got  to the majors, he never changed teams and stayed for almost two decades.

Hint: #2  His team went to the postseason eleven of his 18 seasons with them

Hint: #3  His squad won the World Series twice during his time with them, but he was only able to participate the first time.

A.  ADAM WAINWRIGHT  [B-R Bio]

-  Ans.  On 24-May-2006, in the 5th inning, Wainwright hit a home run on the first pitch of the first at-bat he ever saw in the majors.  He hit it off SFG’s Noah Lowry.  Wainwright was the G’s winning pitcher, Lowry the loser.  He added 9 more for a total of 10 career HR.  Wainwright finished 3rd (2009), 2nd (2010), 2nd (2013) & 3rd (2014) in CYA voting, acknowledging that Lincecum, Halladay & Kershaw were formidable ballot opponents.

-  #1  Wainwright pitched for STL for 18 season, 2005-2023.

-  #2  Played 2005-2010; 2012-2023; reached postseason in 2005-06, 2009, 2012-15, 2019-23.

-  #3  STL won the WS in 2006 & again in 2011, but Wainwright was recovering from “Tommy John” surgery in 2011.

FCR -  Marc Brubaker, Houston

Incorrect guesses:  Frank Tanana, Bob Gibson, Warren Spahn

 

 

SATURDAY  — 14-Dec

Q.  Which heterochromatic triple Cy Young Award winner is not done yet?

Hint: #1 His current career WAR is greater than those of retired Hall of Famers Carl Hubbell, Whitey Ford, Jim Palmer Sandy Koufax.

Hint: #2  A fellow Cy Young Award winner and former teammate calls him “a machine”.

A.  MAX SCHERZER  [B-R Bio]

-  Ans.  Scherzer, although currently an unsigned free agent, has publicly stated that he is not considering retirement.

-  #1  With another of his typical seasons, he could easily also pass Robin Roberts, Nolan Ryan & Bob Gibson.

-  #2  Full quote is, "He's definitely a different breed, always has been.  Just seeing the way he goes about things.  He's a machine."  ~ David Price, w/Scherzer on DET (2014) & LAD (2021).

FCR -  Richard Vachet, Belchertown, Massachusetts

Incorrect guesses:  Justin Verlander, Clayton Kershaw, Roger Clemens, Chris Sale

 

 

SUNDAY   — 15-Dec

Q.  Which All-Star pitchers has won World Series rings with three different teams, at least one in each league and at least one in different time zones?

Hint: #1  He once played in a World Series that had nine other postseason series MVPs in uniform.

Hint: #2  His pitching record in American League Championship Series play was a perfect 8-0.

A.  DAVE STEWART  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  Stewart has WS rings from 1981 w/LAD; 1989 w/OAK; & 1993 w/TOR.

-  #1  In the 1993 WS, these postseason MVPs were present and in uniform:

Year     Series  Team          Name  (1993 WS connection)

1955... WS........... BRO......... Johnny Podres (Phillies pitching coach)

1972... WS........... OAK......... Gene Tenace (Blue Jays’ dugout coach)

1983... Clg.WS*... OK St....... Pete Incaviglia (Phillies LF)

1989... ALCS....... OAK......... Rickey Henderson (Blue Jays LF)

1989... WS........... OAK......... Dave Stewart (Blue Jays starting pitcher)

1990... ALCS....... OAK......... Dave Stewart (Blue Jays starting pitcher)

1991... WS........... MIN.......... Jack Morris (Blue Jays bullpen.  In uniform; did not play.)

1992... ALCS....... TOR......... Roberto Alomar (Blue Jays 2nd baseman)

1992... WS........... TOR......... Pat Borders (Blue Jays catcher)

1993... NLCS....... PHI........... Curt Schilling (Phillies starting pitcher)

1993... ALCS....... TOR......... Dave Stewart (Blue Jays starting pitcher)

1993... WS........... TOR......... Paul Molitor (Blue Jays DH)

2001... WS........... ARI........... Curt Schilling (Phillies starting pitcher)

*NCAA college WS,  Played for OK St.

-  #2  Stewart pitched in the ALCS for OAK (6-0) & TOR (2-0)

FCR -  Bruce Duncan, Niceville, Florida

Incorrect guesses:  Will Smith, Jack Morris

 

 

SUNDAY EXTRA  — 15-Dec

Q.  Who was the first pitcher to lead the majors in ERA while pitching for an expansion franchise?

Hint: #1  He was the last Boston native to play for the Boston Braves.

Hint: #2  He was fortunate to have eleven Hall of Famers as teammates.

A.  DICK DONOVAN  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  In 1961, with the newly-launched Washington Senators, a team that lost 100 G that year, Donovan led everybody with a 2.40 ERA.

-  #1  B. 07-Dec-1927 in Boston.  Player for BSN 1950, 1951, 1952.

-  #2  His Hall of Fame teammates were Billy Southworth (Mgr.), Warren Spahn, Eddie Mathews, Al Kaline, Nellie Fox, George Kell, Minnie Minoso, Luis Aparicio, Larry Doby, Al Lopez (Mgr.), Early Wynn (2 X).

FCR -  Terry Gans, San Carlos, California

Incorrect guesses:  John Lackey, Dean Chance

 

 

SUNDAY BONUS  — 15-Dec

Q.  Which one-time Red Sox pitcher was the last Dodgers hurler to have more than ten complete games in a season?

Hint: #1  He was the first pitcher to win a game against the expansion Miami/Florida Marlins.

Hint: #2  Baseball-Reference says he bats left-handed.  Wikipedia list him as a switch-hitter.  ChatGPT asserts that he bats only right-handed

A.  RAMON MARTINEZ  [SABR Bio]

-  Ans.  In 1990, Martinez completed 12 MLB G for LAD.  Pitched for BOS in 1999 & 2000.

-  #1  In their 2nd ever G, the Marlins on 06-Apr-1993 were beaten by Martinez & the Dodgers.

-  #2  ¿Qien sabe?

FCR -  Bill Deane, Cooperstown

Incorrect guesses:  Charlie Hough, Pedro Martinez

 

 

WEEK’S FINALE  — 15-Dec

Q.  Who was the first player in the Korean Baseball Organization history to go directly from the KBO to Major League Baseball via the posting system?

Hint: #1  He won both the KBO MVP and the KBO Rookie of the Year Award before coming to MLB.

Hint: #2  One day after a teammate threw a no-hitter, he was perfect through seven.

A.  HYUN-JIN RYU  [B-R Bio]

-  Ans.  The Los Angeles Dodgers won the bidding rights in 2012, signing him to a 6-year, $36 million deal.

-  #1  He won both awards in the same season, 2006, the first KBO player to do so.

-  #2  On 26-May-2014, Ryu held CIN off the bases until the 8th inning.  On 25-May-2014 teammate Josh Beckett no-hit PHI.

FCR -  Steve Berman, Bergenfield, New Jersey

Incorrect guesses:  Chan Ho Park

 

 WEEK’S THEME – Players whose solitary vote spoiled a unanimous vote for the winner of a Cy Young award

 

Year                 Winner                    Team     #    1-Vote guy                   Team

2021 AL CYA. Robbie Ray..............TOR.... 15....... Cole....................... CHW

 

2021 AL CYA. Warren Spahn..........MLN.... 29....... Donovan.................NYY

 

1988 AL CYA. Frank Viola...............MIN..... 27....... Eckersley.................OAK

 

1990 NL CYA. Doug Drabek............PIT...... 23....... Martinez...................LAD

 

1969 NL CYA. Tom Seaver..............NYM... 23....... Niekro.......................ATL

 

1970 NL CYA Bob Gibson...............STL..... 23....... Perry....................... SFO

 

1980 NL CYA. Steve Carlton...........PHI..... 23....... Reuss....................... LAD

 

2018 NL CYA. Jacob deGrom.........PHI..... 29....... Scherzer......................WSN

 

2019 NL CYA. Jacob deGrom.........PHI..... 29....... Ryu.............................. LAD

 

1989 AL CYA. Bret Saberhagen......KCR.... 27....... Stewart....................... OAK

 

2013 NL CYA. Clayton Kershaw.....LAD.... 29....... Wainwright..................STL    

 

First Correct Respondent identifying theme – {The null set}

 

 

Incorrect theme guesses:

 

Mon     -  300 career wins and 3,000 career strikeouts

 

Tues    -  Members of the 1975 Indians

-   Hall of fame pitchers that had opening day starts for Cleveland

-   Players in multiple teams' Halls of Fame

-   Pitcher who had a complete-game victory in a win-or-go-home Division Series game

 

If you know someone who would enjoy receiving daily Horsehide Trivia questions, they need only drop an email request to horsehidetrivia@aol.com.

 

Click here => THIS WEEK’s quiz, compete with questions, answers and even the incorrect guesses.

 

Scroll back to see previous Horsehide Trivia posts as far back as 2010.  Quizzes before that may also be available upon request.

 

 

Horsehide Trivia encourages independent research.  ⚾️